Retro XM177E2 Comparison: Brownells vs. Troy
This review compares the Brownells and Troy XM177E2 retro AR carbine replicas. The Troy model excels in historical accuracy with its collapsible stock, locking nut, and finish, while the Brownells version features a modern stock and castle nut, and exhibits a quality control issue with a cracked forward assist. Both aim for the XM177E2 aesthetic, with Troy offering more period-correct details and accessories despite a slightly lower price point.









