Retro XM177E2 Comparison: Brownells vs. Troy

Published on April 18, 2018
Duration: 27:39

This review compares the Brownells and Troy XM177E2 retro AR carbine replicas. The Troy model excels in historical accuracy with its collapsible stock, locking nut, and finish, while the Brownells version features a modern stock and castle nut, and exhibits a quality control issue with a cracked forward assist. Both aim for the XM177E2 aesthetic, with Troy offering more period-correct details and accessories despite a slightly lower price point.

Quick Summary

The Troy XM177E2 replica offers superior historical accuracy with its aluminum collapsible stock, spanner nut, and gray parkerized finish. The Brownells version uses a polymer stock and black anodizing, and was observed to have a cracked forward assist, making the Troy the preferred choice for authenticity.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Historical Context: XM177 Origins
  2. 03:12Troy XM177E2 Walkthrough & Features
  3. 09:39Brownells XM177E2 Walkthrough & Features
  4. 13:21Packaging and Accessories Comparison
  5. 20:00XM177 Sound Moderator & Grenade Ring Explained

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Brownells and Troy XM177E2 replicas?

The Troy replica prioritizes historical accuracy with an aluminum collapsible stock and spanner nut, finished in gray parkerizing. The Brownells version uses a polymer stock, a modern castle nut, and black anodizing, and was noted to have a cracked forward assist.

Which XM177E2 replica is more historically accurate?

The Troy XM177E2 replica is generally considered more historically accurate due to its period-correct aluminum collapsible stock, spanner-wrench style locking nut, and gray parkerized finish, compared to the Brownells model's modern polymer stock and black anodizing.

What accessories are included with the Troy and Brownells XM177E2 rifles?

The Troy ($1199) includes 20 and 30-round magazines, a cleaning kit, a special ops sling, and reproduction manuals. The Brownells ($1299) comes with fewer accessories, primarily a 20-round magazine and a manual.

What was the purpose of the XM177's sound moderator?

The XM177's sound moderator served multiple functions: flash suppression, increasing backpressure for reliable cycling of the short barrel, and slightly moderating the sound signature to potentially confuse enemy combatants.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Military Arms Channel

View all →