Ruger SR9 versus Glock 19 Mud Test:

Published on March 10, 2015
Duration: 14:13

This video from TFB TV features James Reeves conducting an extreme mud test comparing the Ruger SR9 and Glock 19. The test assesses their reliability when subjected to heavy contamination after being stripped of lubrication. The Glock 19 demonstrated superior performance in adverse conditions, while the Ruger SR9 experienced significant malfunctions.

Quick Summary

In an extreme mud test by TFB TV, the Glock 19 demonstrated superior reliability compared to the Ruger SR9. After being stripped of lubrication and submerged in mud, the Glock 19 eventually 'shot itself clean,' while the Ruger SR9 suffered from grit ingress causing feeding and magazine retention failures.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Comparison
  2. 01:51Test Preparation
  3. 02:14Dry Function Test (SR9)
  4. 03:43The Mud Test
  5. 06:21Glock 19 Performance
  6. 09:29Final Assessment

Frequently Asked Questions

How did the Ruger SR9 and Glock 19 perform in an extreme mud test?

In a mud test conducted by TFB TV's James Reeves, the Glock 19 proved more reliable. After being stripped of lubrication and submerged in mud, the Glock 19 eventually cycled a full magazine, while the Ruger SR9 experienced significant failures including feeding issues and magazine release problems.

What factors contributed to the Ruger SR9's failure in the mud test?

The Ruger SR9's tight tolerances allowed grit to infiltrate its trigger and firing pin channel, causing it to seize. Additionally, the magazine release mechanism was particularly susceptible to mud ingress, leading to failures in magazine retention.

Is the Glock 19 considered more reliable than the Ruger SR9 in adverse conditions?

Yes, the video demonstrates that the Glock 19 is the more reliable choice for extreme environments. While the Ruger SR9 offers advantages like a lower bore axis and better trigger, its susceptibility to dirt in harsh conditions makes the Glock 19 the preferred option for reliability.

What preparation was done before the mud test on the Ruger SR9 and Glock 19?

Before the mud test, both the Ruger SR9 and Glock 19 were stripped of their factory lubrication. This was achieved by using non-chlorinated brake cleaner to ensure the firearms were completely dry, allowing for a more accurate assessment of their performance under extreme conditions.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from TFB TV

View all →