Scar 17: A Polarizing, Iconic Rifle

Published on November 19, 2021
Duration: 26:31

This video provides an in-depth review of the FN SCAR 17, exploring its history, technical specifications, and polarizing reputation. The presenter, drawing on insights from Green Berets and his own testing, emphasizes the SCAR's effectiveness as a Designated Marksman Rifle (DMR). Key aspects discussed include its short-stroke gas piston system, accuracy potential, the impact of aftermarket modifications like rails and triggers, and its performance under various conditions, while also addressing common criticisms regarding its weight and charging handle.

Quick Summary

The FN SCAR 17 is best suited for a Designated Marksman Rifle (DMR) role, excelling in engagements from 200 to 800 meters. While known for being hard on optics, requiring scar-rated versions, its reliability is high, averaging over 3000 rounds per malfunction in SOCOM tests.

Chapters

  1. 02:05Introduction & Cold Weather Filming
  2. 02:47The FN SCAR: Iconic & Controversial
  3. 03:15Gun Source: Strapped Armory Phoenix
  4. 03:54Initial Bias & Opinion Change
  5. 04:30SCAR Development Timeline (2002-2009)
  6. 05:05First SOCOM Unit to Field SCAR
  7. 05:56Development Cost & Hefty Price Tag
  8. 06:37Technical Specs: Piston System, Barrel, Upper
  9. 07:49SCAR Accuracy: 1 MOA Potential
  10. 08:18Range Testing & Round Count
  11. 08:36Ambi Controls & Reciprocating Charging Handle
  12. 09:24Enlarged Trigger Guard & Folding Stock
  13. 09:50Aftermarket Triggers: Geissele Upgrade
  14. 10:45Optic Zeroing: 100 Meters
  15. 11:10SCAR 17 Price Point
  16. 11:43Dismantling for Accessory Overview
  17. 11:53Suppressor: CGS Hyperion K (Direct Thread)
  18. 12:41Bipod, Grip, and Optic Setup
  19. 13:04Optics Abuse: SCAR-Rated Requirements
  20. 14:13Aftermarket Rail: KDG M-REX
  21. 14:56Charging Handle Gripes & Rail Solution
  22. 15:25Magazine Release & Bad Lever
  23. 15:53Total Build Cost: $7,600 - $8,000
  24. 16:42SOCOM Testing Standards: Reliability
  25. 18:19Suppressor Use & Warranty Concerns
  26. 18:54Seals vs. Green Berets: Reliability Context
  27. 19:20Right Tool for the Right Job: CQB vs. DMR
  28. 20:00Malfunctions in Cold/High Altitude Conditions
  29. 21:01Common Gripes & Rebuttals (Length, Weight)
  30. 22:01Sniper Qualification with SCAR
  31. 22:28Typical Engagement Ranges (200-800m)
  32. 22:47SCAR Shines as a DMR
  33. 23:17Final Thoughts & Preconceived Notions
  34. 23:55Final Thoughts & Desire to Own
  35. 25:23Sex Appeal & Aesthetics
  36. 26:00Conclusion: Right Tool for the Job

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the primary role for which the FN SCAR 17 is best suited?

The FN SCAR 17 truly shines as a Designated Marksman Rifle (DMR). Its design and capabilities make it highly effective for engagements typically ranging from 200 to 800 meters, providing precision and reliability in this specific role.

Why are SCAR rifles known to be hard on optics, and what is recommended?

SCAR rifles can be very hard on optics due to their recoil impulse and operational stresses. Some optics require 'scar-rated' versions specifically designed to withstand this abuse, as standard optics may fail internally around 1,000 rounds.

What are the main criticisms of the FN SCAR 17, and how are they addressed?

Common criticisms include its weight, length, and the reciprocating charging handle, particularly for CQB. However, in its intended DMR role, these are less problematic. Aftermarket rails can also improve ergonomics and mitigate charging handle issues.

What were the reliability standards for the FN SCAR during SOCOM testing?

During extensive SOCOM testing, the FN SCAR demonstrated high reliability, averaging approximately 3060 rounds per malfunction. This significantly exceeded the requirement of one malfunction per 2,000 rounds over a 15,000-round test period.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from 1911 Syndicate

View all →