The BEST Concealed Carry Gun?! Shield Plus vs p365

Published on June 9, 2021
Duration: 12:58

This review compares the Sig Sauer P365XL and the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus for concealed carry. The Shield Plus is praised for its superior trigger, thinner profile, and easier magazine loading, making it a strong contender for the 'best' carry gun. The P365XL offers higher capacity but has a trigger guard issue and is thicker. Both firearms were tested with various ammunition types, with the Shield Plus demonstrating reliable cycling.

Quick Summary

The Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus is often preferred for concealed carry over the Sig Sauer P365XL due to its significantly thinner profile and superior out-of-the-box trigger. While the P365XL offers higher capacity, the Shield Plus provides better ergonomics and easier magazine loading, making it a top choice for everyday carry.

Chapters

  1. 00:14Sig Sauer P365XL Introduction
  2. 00:37P365XL Shooting - Standard Mag
  3. 00:56P365XL Extended Magazine
  4. 01:13P365XL Shooting - Extended Mag
  5. 01:39P365XL Performance and Capacity
  6. 01:50P365XL Criticisms - Sig P320 Drop Safe Issue
  7. 02:23P365XL Trigger Issue
  8. 02:54P365XL Trigger Replacement Cost
  9. 03:21S&W M&P Shield Plus Introduction
  10. 03:38Shield Plus Sponsor Mention
  11. 03:47Shield Plus Initial Impressions
  12. 04:00Shield Plus Shooting
  13. 04:18Shield Plus Trigger Comparison
  14. 05:08Shield Plus Standard Magazine
  15. 05:26Shield Plus Shooting - Extended Mag
  16. 05:57P365XL vs. Shield Plus Size Comparison (Short Mags)
  17. 06:16P365XL vs. Shield Plus Thickness Comparison
  18. 06:58P365XL vs. Shield Plus Slide and Overall Size
  19. 07:07P365XL vs. Shield Plus Size Comparison (Extended Mags)
  20. 07:35Shield Plus External Thumb Safety
  21. 07:53Shield Plus Magazine Loading
  22. 08:04Shield Plus Ammunition Testing - Winchester White Box
  23. 08:36Shield Plus Ammunition Testing - Sig V-Crown
  24. 09:13Shield Plus Ammunition Testing - Speer Gold Dot
  25. 09:37Shield Plus Ammunition Cycling Summary
  26. 09:46"Wheelgun" Shooting Drill
  27. 10:19Shield Plus Ammunition Testing - Devastators
  28. 11:09Devastator Ammo Shooting
  29. 11:21Shield Plus Shooting - Final Thoughts
  30. 12:08Shield Plus Review Conclusion
  31. 12:21Firearms Hobby Cost and Evolution

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Sig Sauer P365XL and the S&W M&P Shield Plus for concealed carry?

The S&W M&P Shield Plus is generally considered superior for concealed carry due to its significantly thinner profile and a much better out-of-the-box trigger. The P365XL offers higher capacity but has a thicker grip and a trigger guard that can be difficult to use, especially with gloves.

How does the trigger quality compare between the P365XL and the Shield Plus?

The Shield Plus's trigger is praised as one of the nicest available without modification, featuring a nearly flat face and a crisp break. The P365XL's trigger is a primary complaint due to limited space in the trigger guard, making it awkward to operate, particularly with gloves.

Which handgun is easier to load magazines for, the P365XL or the Shield Plus?

The magazines for the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus are noted as being much easier to load compared to the Sig Sauer P365XL. The P365XL's magazines can be difficult to load to their full capacity.

What are the capacity differences between the Sig Sauer P365XL and the S&W M&P Shield Plus?

The Sig Sauer P365XL typically holds 11 or 12 rounds in its standard magazine and can accept a 15+1 extended magazine. The S&W M&P Shield Plus comes with a 10+1 standard magazine and a 13+1 extended magazine.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from 1ShotTV

View all →