The Top 5 Overrated Concealed Carry Guns

Published on October 11, 2016
Duration: 11:42

James Reeves, a recognized firearms reviewer, critically examines five popular concealed carry firearms, arguing they are overrated for their intended purpose. He provides detailed reasoning, comparing specifications, reliability, and practical carry considerations, offering alternative recommendations for dedicated EDC.

Quick Summary

Firearms expert James Reeves argues that popular concealed carry guns like the Glock 19, revolvers, Kel-Tecs, certain Walthers/HKs, and the 1911 are overrated. He cites issues such as excessive size/weight for the Glock 19, low capacity and inefficiency for revolvers, and reliability concerns for Kel-Tecs and 1911s, suggesting smaller alternatives like the Glock 43 or 26 for better EDC practicality.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Overrated CCWs
  2. 00:14#5: Glock 19
  3. 01:47#4: Revolvers
  4. 03:51#3: Kel-Tec Handguns
  5. 05:18#2: German Handguns (Walther & HK)
  6. 07:44#1: The 1911

Frequently Asked Questions

Which concealed carry guns are considered overrated by firearms expert James Reeves?

James Reeves identifies the Glock 19, revolvers (like S&W Airweight), Kel-Tec handguns (P3AT, PF9), certain Walther and HK models, and the 1911 platform as overrated for concealed carry due to issues like size, weight, capacity, and reliability concerns.

Why is the Glock 19 considered overrated for concealed carry?

While a capable firearm, the Glock 19 is considered overrated for dedicated concealed carry because its 'compact' designation is debatable; its size and weight (approx 1.5 lbs) make it less ideal than smaller options like the Glock 43 or 26 for deep concealment.

What are the main criticisms of the 1911 for concealed carry?

The 1911 platform is criticized as the most overrated CCW due to its substantial weight (around 40 oz), low capacity (typically 7-8 rounds), and the high cost required to ensure its reliability for self-defense, making lighter, higher-capacity options more practical.

What alternatives does James Reeves suggest for concealed carry?

For those finding the commonly recommended guns overrated, Reeves suggests considering smaller, lighter firearms like the Glock 43 or Glock 26 for better concealability. He implies that practical considerations should outweigh marketing hype.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from TFB TV

View all →