Walther P22Q versus Ruger SR22P - Ergo’s, ammo testing, reliability. 22LR goodness!

Published on July 7, 2024
Duration: 21:06

This review compares the Walther P22Q and Ruger SR22P .22LR pistols, focusing on ergonomics, reliability with various ammunition types, and trigger feel. The speaker notes the Ruger SR22P generally exhibits better reliability across a wider range of ammunition and offers a more comfortable grip for larger hands, while the Walther P22Q is a more budget-friendly option that performs best with higher-velocity ammunition.

Quick Summary

The Ruger SR22P generally proves more reliable across a wider variety of .22LR ammunition compared to the Walther P22Q. While the P22Q is more budget-friendly, it often requires higher velocity rounds and can be finicky with certain primers and cycling. The SR22P's ergonomics are also favored by many for its more accommodating grip.

Chapters

  1. 00:26Introduction & Comparison Setup
  2. 00:56Pistol Similarities & Differences
  3. 01:34Testing Focus: Feel & Reliability
  4. 01:51Ammunition Selection for Testing
  5. 03:09Arms Core 36gr HP Testing
  6. 04:50Federal 36gr HP Testing
  7. 06:07Remington Golden Bullet Testing
  8. 06:56Winchester Silver Tip Testing
  9. 09:57CCI Blazer 40gr Lead Testing
  10. 11:49Federal Auto Match Testing
  11. 13:37Aguila Super Extra Testing
  12. 15:15Ergonomics & Reliability Summary
  13. 16:47Overall Preference & Quality
  14. 17:12Price Comparison
  15. 18:00Remington Viper Testing
  16. 19:23Final Thoughts & Recommendations

Frequently Asked Questions

Which .22LR pistol is generally more reliable between the Walther P22Q and Ruger SR22P?

Based on testing with various ammunition types, the Ruger SR22P generally exhibits better reliability across a wider range of loads compared to the Walther P22Q. The Walther P22Q can be finicky with certain ammunition, often requiring higher velocity rounds for consistent cycling and ignition.

How do the ergonomics of the Walther P22Q and Ruger SR22P compare?

The Ruger SR22P offers a slightly longer grip, accommodating three fingers more comfortably, especially with extended magazine base plates. The Walther P22Q's grip can feel cramped for some shooters, and its slide-mounted safety can interfere with racking the slide.

What types of ammunition did the Walther P22Q struggle with?

The Walther P22Q showed reliability issues with Winchester Silver Tip 37-grain plated hollow points and CCI Blazer 40-grain lead round nose ammunition. These rounds often failed to cycle the action fully or required a second strike to ignite the primer.

What are the key differences in materials and price between the Walther P22Q and Ruger SR22P?

The Walther P22Q features a Zamac (zinc alloy) slide and is more budget-friendly, typically costing $200-$250. The Ruger SR22P has a machined aluminum slide and is priced higher, usually between $379-$450, reflecting its perceived build quality and reliability.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Cranky Gun Reviews

View all →