Was This Really The Worst U.S. Military Pistol?

Published on June 26, 2025
Duration: 9:36

This video delves into the history and performance of the Beretta M9 as a US military sidearm, questioning if it was truly the 'worst.' While acknowledging its initial issues like slide cracking and ergonomic challenges, the discussion highlights its reliability after fixes and its eventual replacement by the SIG Sauer M17/M18. Modernized Beretta variants like the M9A4 are presented as significant improvements addressing the M9's shortcomings.

Quick Summary

The Beretta M9, adopted in 1985, initially suffered from slide cracking issues that were later resolved. While reliable post-fix, its ergonomics and limited accessory mounting were criticized, leading to its replacement by the SIG Sauer M17/M18. Modern variants like the M9A4 offer significant improvements.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: M9 vs. M1911A
  2. 00:37Beretta M9: The Question of Performance
  3. 01:02Personal Opinion on Beretta Firearms
  4. 01:34The M9 Replaces the 1911
  5. 01:54Capacity and NATO Standards
  6. 02:19M9 Issues: Slide Cracking
  7. 02:31M9 Design: Non-Tilting Barrel
  8. 02:37Ergonomic Challenges of the M9
  9. 02:47Accessory Limitations
  10. 02:55M9 Service History and Iterations
  11. 03:16Modern M9 Variants: A3 and A4
  12. 03:57Why the M17/M18 Replaced the M9
  13. 04:20Cost Factors in Military Contracts
  14. 04:54M9 vs. P320: Frame Design
  15. 05:17M9 Reliability Post-Fix
  16. 05:31Ergonomic Gripes with the M9
  17. 06:05Subjectivity of Ergonomics
  18. 06:11Improvements in M9A4
  19. 06:36Preference for the M9A4
  20. 06:49M9 Decocker and Immediate Action
  21. 07:07Sharp Edges and Ergonomics
  22. 07:29Weight as a Complaint
  23. 07:52M9 vs. P320: Customization
  24. 08:07Conclusion: Good Gun or Bad Gun?
  25. 08:21Reliability Recap
  26. 08:42Audience Stories and Evolving Tactics
  27. 09:01Modern Solutions for Modern Times
  28. 09:14Beretta's Development Strategy
  29. 09:27Final Thoughts and Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

Did the Beretta M9 have significant reliability issues?

Initially, the Beretta M9 faced critical issues with slide cracking and fracturing. However, these problems were addressed and fixed by Beretta in later production runs, leading to generally good reliability thereafter.

What are the main ergonomic complaints about the Beretta M9?

Users often cite sharp edges on the M9's frame, particularly around the slide release and trigger guard, which can cause cuts during aggressive manipulation like tap-rack drills. The grip angle may also not be ideal for all hand sizes.

Why was the Beretta M9 replaced by the SIG Sauer M17/M18?

The M9 was replaced by the SIG Sauer M17/M18 due to factors including cost, the military's desire for a more modular platform with a Fire Control Unit (FCU), and advancements in handgun technology that the M9's design evolution didn't fully keep pace with.

Are there modernized versions of the Beretta M9?

Yes, Beretta has released modernized versions such as the M9A1, M9A3, and M9A4. The M9A4, in particular, features an optics-ready slide, Picatinny rail, improved grip texture, and a slimmer grip profile to enhance its tactical capabilities and ergonomics.

Related News

All News โ†’

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from ClassicFirearms

View all โ†’