Why Do People Hate The 1911 (vs Glock)

Published on November 30, 2021
Duration: 11:20

This video compares the SDS Bantam Carry 1911 in .45 ACP with a Glock 19 Gen 5 in 9mm, highlighting key differences in triggers, recoil, capacity, and safety features. While acknowledging the 1911's superior trigger and aesthetic appeal, the video discusses common criticisms like lower capacity and the external thumb safety. The Glock is noted for its higher capacity, milder recoil impulse, and simpler operation, making it a practical choice for many. The presenter, while not a dedicated 1911 enthusiast, expresses appreciation for the platform's unique characteristics.

Quick Summary

The 1911 pistol is celebrated for its superior trigger quality and classic aesthetics, making it a pleasure to shoot. However, common criticisms include lower ammunition capacity due to single-stack magazines, the added step of an external thumb safety, and a higher cost compared to modern polymer handguns.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & 1911 Tease
  2. 00:48Introducing the SDS Bantam Carry 1911
  3. 01:111911 Pros: Triggers & Aesthetics
  4. 02:011911 Cons: .45 ACP Recoil & Capacity
  5. 02:501911 Cons: External Thumb Safety
  6. 03:26Introducing the Glock 19 Gen 5
  7. 03:58Glock 9mm Recoil vs 1911 .45 ACP
  8. 04:15Recoil Test: 9mm vs .45 ACP Speed
  9. 05:05Shooting Comparison: 1911 vs Glock
  10. 05:57Capacity Differences: 1911 vs Glock
  11. 06:451911 Price Point & Value
  12. 09:10Malfunction During Shooting Drill
  13. 10:011911 Growing On The Presenter
  14. 10:34Conclusion & Final Thoughts

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main advantages of the 1911 pistol?

The 1911 is renowned for its exceptionally crisp and clean trigger pull, widely considered one of the best handgun triggers available. Additionally, 1911s are often praised for their classic, beautiful design and comfortable ergonomics, making them very pleasant to shoot.

What are common criticisms leveled against the 1911 platform?

Common criticisms include lower ammunition capacity due to single-stack magazines, the presence of an external thumb safety which adds an operational step, and a generally higher price point compared to modern polymer pistols. The .45 ACP caliber also has a more pronounced recoil than 9mm.

How does the Glock 19 Gen 5 compare to the 1911 in terms of shooting experience?

The Glock 19 Gen 5, in 9mm, offers a milder recoil impulse that allows for faster sight re-acquisition and quicker follow-up shots. Its higher capacity magazines and simpler operation are also key advantages for many users, though its trigger is generally considered less refined than a 1911's.

Is the .45 ACP caliber in a 1911 significantly harder to shoot than 9mm in a Glock?

While the .45 ACP has a more substantial recoil impulse, it's not excessively powerful for most shooters. The primary difference noted is the speed of follow-up shots; the 9mm in a Glock often allows for faster sight return to target, making it feel 'snappier' but more conducive to rapid shooting.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from 1ShotTV

View all →