Why were they flops? What went wrong?

Published on April 4, 2025
Duration: 23:08

This video reviews the Beretta ARX100 and IWI Carmel, discussing why they were anticipated but ultimately underperformed in the market. The ARX100 faced criticism for its extensive polymer use, wobbly rail, short stock, and proprietary sling mounts, though its ambidextrous ejection and charging handle were noted positives. The IWI Carmel, while praised for its lightweight design, good ergonomics, and accuracy, was hampered by its '2x4' looking handguard and departure from prototype aesthetics, leading to market disappointment despite its solid engineering.

Quick Summary

The Beretta ARX100 was criticized for its polymer construction, wobbly rail, short stock, and proprietary sling mounts, while the IWI Carmel was hampered by its unappealing handguard design despite good ergonomics and accuracy. Both were highly anticipated but failed to meet market expectations.

Chapters

  1. 00:10Introduction: Anticipated Firearms That Flopped
  2. 00:35Beretta ARX100: The 'AR-15 Killer'?
  3. 01:47ARX100: Early Hype and Market Reception
  4. 02:54ARX100: Criticisms and Problems
  5. 03:04Polymer Concerns with the ARX100
  6. 03:41ARX100: Wobbling Top Rail Issue
  7. 04:25ARX100: Short Stock and Promised Replacements
  8. 04:58ARX100: Unfulfilled Cartridge Conversion Promises
  9. 05:14ARX100: Strap Sling Mounts vs. QD
  10. 05:40ARX100: Ergonomic Criticisms
  11. 06:09ARX100: Early Generation Features (Grenade Launcher Mount)
  12. 06:31ARX100: Non-Swappable Pistol Grip
  13. 06:50ARX100: Quick Change Barrel and Accuracy Concerns
  14. 07:51ARX100: Charging Handle and Skin Scraping Issue
  15. 08:45ARX100: PMAG Compatibility Issues
  16. 09:11ARX100: Heavy Trigger Pull
  17. 09:21ARX100: Durability Issues and Broken Parts
  18. 10:36ARX100: Positive Features - Reliability
  19. 10:57ARX100: Ambidextrous Ejection System
  20. 11:56ARX100: Engineering - Dual Function Extractor/Ejector
  21. 13:21ARX100: Ambidextrous Charging Handle Conversion
  22. 13:42ARX100: Bolt Hold/Release Feature
  23. 14:04ARX100: Quick Barrel Removal Feature
  24. 14:27ARX100: Overall Assessment - Interesting but Not Superior
  25. 14:57IWI Carmel: Similar Trajectory to ARX100
  26. 15:20Carmel: Expectations vs. Prototype Handguard
  27. 15:53Carmel: US-Designed Production Model
  28. 16:09Carmel: The '2x4' Handguard Criticism
  29. 17:24Carmel: Americanizing Firearms - A Market Mistake?
  30. 17:35Carmel: Blocky Handguard Ergonomics
  31. 17:50Carmel: Lightweight Design and Good Heft
  32. 18:28Carmel: Positive Features - Lightweight and Polymers
  33. 18:33Carmel: Adjustable Stock and Cheek Riser
  34. 18:54Carmel: Rigid Receiver and Bolted Rail
  35. 19:22Carmel: Ergonomics and Ambidextrous Controls
  36. 19:48Carmel: Ambidextrous Charging Handle
  37. 20:11Carmel: Accuracy and Gas Piston System
  38. 20:30Carmel: Solid Design, Hampered by Appearance
  39. 20:49Carmel: Price and Market Value
  40. 21:23Carmel: Potential Modern Collectible?
  41. 21:52Conclusion: Collectible Potential and Availability

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the main criticisms of the Beretta ARX100?

The Beretta ARX100 faced criticism for its extensive use of polymer, a wobbly top rail attached to the receiver, a very short stock, proprietary sling mounts, and an awkward charging handle that could scrape knuckles. Additionally, Gen 3 PMAGs were incompatible, and the trigger pull was heavy.

Why did the IWI Carmel fail to gain market traction despite its features?

The IWI Carmel's market performance was hindered by its '2x4' looking handguard, which differed significantly from the more appealing prototype. This aesthetic issue, coupled with the perception of 'Americanization' of the design, deterred potential buyers despite the rifle's lightweight construction, good ergonomics, and accuracy.

What are the key ambidextrous features of the Beretta ARX100?

The Beretta ARX100 offers ambidextrous ejection, allowing users to switch the ejection port from right to left without tools. It also features an ambidextrous charging handle that can be moved to either side of the receiver, enhancing its usability for left-handed shooters.

What makes the IWI Carmel a good shooting rifle?

The IWI Carmel is considered a good shooting rifle due to its lightweight design, excellent ergonomics, and balanced feel. It features a short-stroke gas piston system, an adjustable gas regulator, and a good trigger, contributing to a pleasant recoil impulse and overall shooting experience.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Military Arms Channel

View all →