Sheriff Warns About New Legal Open Carry Laws

Published on September 23, 2025
Duration: 10:00

Colion Noir critically examines Florida's new open carry law, arguing that while a win for 2A rights, it presents significant tactical disadvantages. He highlights Sheriff Grady Judd's warning that open carry does not deter criminals and can make carriers priority targets, citing visual evidence of gun snatching. Noir concludes that concealed carry remains tactically superior due to the element of surprise.

Quick Summary

Colion Noir critically examines Florida's new open carry law, arguing that while a win for 2A rights, it presents significant tactical disadvantages. He highlights Sheriff Grady Judd's warning that open carry does not deter criminals and can make carriers priority targets, citing visual evidence of gun snatching. Noir concludes that concealed carry remains tactically superior due to the element of surprise.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Florida's New Open Carry Law
  2. 00:54Legal Protection of Open Carry
  3. 02:05Tactical Critique of Open Carry
  4. 02:30Sheriff Grady Judd's Warning
  5. 03:07Visual Evidence of Gun Snatching
  6. 04:37The Advantage of Concealment
  7. 06:22Open Carriers as Priority Targets
  8. 08:27Conclusion: Concealed Carry Superiority

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the tactical disadvantages of open carry according to Colion Noir?

Colion Noir argues that open carry makes individuals a priority target for criminals, removing the element of surprise and potentially leading to the firearm being taken and used against the carrier. He states that modern criminals are not deterred by visible firearms and may see them as an opportunity.

Does open carry deter criminals, according to Sheriff Grady Judd?

Sheriff Grady Judd warns that open carry does not scare criminals. Instead, he suggests that a criminal might see an openly carried firearm as an opportunity to take the gun from the carrier and use it against them, making the carrier a target.

Why is concealed carry considered tactically superior to open carry?

Concealed carry provides the critical element of surprise, which is the only remaining advantage in self-defense scenarios. Criminals rely on victims being off-guard; concealment forces hesitation due to uncertainty, whereas open carry removes this tactical advantage.

What is the legal status of open carry in Florida as discussed in the video?

The video mentions that Florida legalized open carry, with the law taking effect on September 25th. While seen as a win for Second Amendment rights, the discussion focuses on the tactical implications and potential risks associated with this new legal allowance.

Related News

All News →

More Self Defense Videos You Might Like

More from Colion Noir

View all →