What weapons and calibers are best for home defense?

This video's title, 'There’s no such thing as overkill when carrying,' strongly suggests a discussion centered around self-defense and the importance of adequate preparedness. It implies an argument for carrying firearms with sufficient capacity and effectiveness to handle potential threats, emphasizing that under-preparation is a greater risk than over-preparation. The content likely explores scenarios and rationales behind choosing specific firearms or calibers for personal protection, aligning with the broader theme of responsible and effective concealed carry.

This video from PewPewDingers demonstrates the effectiveness of 12-gauge slugs and buckshot for home defense using a Genesis Arms Gen12 shotgun. The host advises against birdshot for home defense scenarios. Both slug and buckshot rounds were tested against watermelon targets, showcasing significant destructive power. The demonstration highlights the importance of selecting appropriate ammunition for defensive use.

This guide, based on decades of firearm experience, emphasizes the necessity of owning two specific types of firearms for comprehensive self-defense. The primary recommendation is a concealed carry handgun, serving as an all-around tool for personal security in public and adaptable for home defense. The secondary, crucial firearm is a shotgun, specifically a 12-gauge semi-automatic, for its unparalleled effectiveness in home defense scenarios. The instructor stresses that these two firearms provide a robust defensive capability for most individuals.

This video from Civilian Tactical explores three everyday carry (EDC) firearm choices, demonstrating practical application and selection criteria. The presenter, exhibiting experienced authority, highlights the Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 2.0 for deep concealment, the Glock 19 as a primary carry option, and the Switch-Gun for pocket carry. The discussion emphasizes the importance of effective ammunition and the utility of red dot sights on compact firearms.

This video explores various aspects of home defense, emphasizing proactive security measures like cameras, locks, and dogs as the primary deterrent. It delves into personal carry preferences, common purchasing mistakes, and factors influencing firearm choice based on home layout and local laws. The discussion includes traditional "go-to" firearms like shotguns and AR-15 variants, alongside modern options and personal staging strategies.

Instruction from TheYankeeMarshal, an experienced firearms instructor, advises against using birdshot and buckshot for home defense in townhouses. Birdshot is deemed ineffective for stopping threats, while buckshot carries a high risk of over-penetration in confined spaces. The instructor recommends handgun calibers like 9mm or .45 ACP with appropriate defensive loads as a more suitable option for townhouse home defense.

This video demonstrates the proper technique for loading the M1 Garand to prevent 'Garand Thumb'. It emphasizes maintaining downward pressure on the top round to control the bolt's cycling. The content debunks the idea that 'Garand Thumb' is inevitable, attributing it to inexperience and improper handling.

The Altyn helmet, a Russian titanium model, is tested for its ballistic capabilities. While effective against 9mm NATO and 00 buckshot, it fails to stop rifle rounds like 5.56x45mm and .308 Winchester. The visor cracks under birdshot impact. Despite its historical reputation, its extreme weight and lack of rifle protection make it outdated compared to modern composite helmets.

This ballistic test by Garand Thumb reveals that NIJ Level 3A rated ballistic masks, while stopping some projectiles, fail to adequately protect the wearer due to extreme backface deformation. Hits from a .44 Magnum caused fatal deformation, and rifle rounds completely penetrated. The conclusion is that these masks are largely ineffective and potentially dangerous, recommending helmets and proper training instead.

This video delves into the notorious 'Garand Thumb' phenomenon, explaining its mechanics and pain level through direct testing. It covers the M1 Garand's history, technical specifications, and proper loading techniques to avoid injury, including the 'bladed hand' method. The content also features novice testing and concludes with advice on training and firearm ownership.