Does EDC Bag Carry Make Sense? Lets Break It Down

Published on October 12, 2024
Duration: 9:30

This video critically examines the practicality and safety of using EDC (Everyday Carry) bags for firearm concealment. The instructor, with apparent experience in firearms instruction, highlights potential drawbacks such as increased suspicion from non-firearm owners, faster acquisition by criminals, and slower draw times under stress compared to traditional concealed carry methods like inside-the-waistband holsters. While acknowledging the convenience for situations lacking pockets, the overall assessment leans against EDC bags as a primary or optimal method for concealed firearm carry due to these identified risks.

Quick Summary

Carrying a firearm in an EDC bag is generally not recommended as a primary method due to increased risks. These bags can draw suspicion, are recognizable by criminals, and may result in slower draw times under stress compared to traditional inside-the-waistband holsters. While convenient in specific situations lacking pockets, the potential drawbacks often outweigh the benefits for effective self-defense.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: EDC Bag Carry Debate
  2. 00:16Sig Sauer Documentary Mention
  3. 00:41Sig Sauer P320 & P365 Part Origins
  4. 00:71945 Industries EDC Bags & Alternatives
  5. 00:86Bag Holster Design & Compatibility
  6. 01:26Personal Experience with Sticky Holster
  7. 01:59Honest Assessment of EDC Bags
  8. 02:10Preferred Concealed Carry Methods
  9. 02:32Who is Coming for Your Firearm?
  10. 02:43EDC Bags as Obvious Firearm Carriers
  11. 02:54Non-Gun Owners Can Spot a Gun Bag
  12. 03:08Robber's Advantage with EDC Bags
  13. 03:30IWB Carry vs. EDC Bag Draw Speed
  14. 03:36Blacksmith Tactical Holster Recommendation
  15. 03:57Criminals Using EDC Bags
  16. 04:04Draw Speed Comparison: EDC Bag vs. Shirt
  17. 04:18Training for Stressful Draws
  18. 04:39Under Stress: Tab vs. Shirt Draw
  19. 04:56Personal Use Cases for EDC Bags
  20. 05:02Suspicion from Other Parents at Park
  21. 05:20Struggle Dynamics: Bag vs. IWB
  22. 05:36One-Handed Draws & Practicality
  23. 05:51Challenge to Think Independently

Frequently Asked Questions

Is carrying a firearm in an EDC bag a good idea?

Carrying a firearm in an EDC bag presents significant risks. While convenient for situations without pockets, it can draw suspicion, be easily identified by criminals, and potentially lead to slower draw times under stress compared to traditional concealed carry methods like inside-the-waistband holsters.

Why might criminals target someone carrying a firearm in an EDC bag?

Criminals are aware that EDC bags are often used for firearm concealment. This makes individuals carrying such bags potential targets for robbery, as the bag clearly signals the presence of a valuable and accessible firearm, allowing for quick acquisition.

How does drawing a firearm from an EDC bag compare to drawing from an IWB holster?

Drawing from an EDC bag typically involves locating and manipulating a pull tab, which can be slower and more complex under duress. In contrast, drawing from an inside-the-waistband holster is a more ingrained, intuitive motion, often faster and more reliable in high-stress situations.

Are there any situations where an EDC bag might be a reasonable option for firearm carry?

An EDC bag might be considered in specific scenarios where traditional pocket carry is impossible, such as on a beach with bathing suits lacking pockets. However, even in these cases, the bag can still attract unwanted attention and carries inherent risks.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from SPN Firearms

View all →