Open vs Closed Holsters: Pros, Cons and Best Draw

Published on May 7, 2026
Duration: 1:07

This video discusses the pros and cons of open and closed holsters, primarily focusing on retention mechanisms like snaps. The speaker differentiates between full top enclosures, which offer maximum retention but hinder draw speed, and holsters with straps or snaps. For snap-equipped holsters, the preferred design places the snap towards the rear for easier thumb activation during a draw, contrasting with front-mounted snaps that require an extra step. The primary pro of closed holsters is enhanced retention, while cons include slower draw times. Open holsters, conversely, offer faster draws but less retention.

Quick Summary

Closed holsters offer superior firearm retention, but can slow down your draw. The placement of retention snaps is key; rear-mounted snaps facilitate a faster draw by allowing easy thumb activation, while front-mounted snaps add an extra step, hindering speed.

Chapters

  1. 00:01Introduction: Open vs. Closed Holsters
  2. 00:10Full Top Enclosure Holsters: Pros and Cons
  3. 00:29Holsters with Straps/Snaps: Design and Draw
  4. 00:43Snap Placement: Front vs. Rear
  5. 00:56Summary of Closed Holster Pros
  6. 01:02Conclusion: Open vs. Closed Trade-offs

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main pros and cons of closed holsters?

The primary pro of closed holsters, especially those with full top enclosures or retention straps, is enhanced firearm retention, keeping the gun secure. The main con is that these mechanisms can significantly slow down your draw speed, requiring extra steps to access the firearm.

How does snap placement affect firearm draw speed from a holster?

Snap placement is crucial for draw speed. A snap located towards the rear of the holster allows for easier thumb activation, enabling a quicker draw. Conversely, a front-mounted snap requires an additional manipulation step, slowing down the draw process.

What is the advantage of an open holster compared to a closed one?

The main advantage of an open holster is its speed of draw. Lacking any retention straps or full enclosures, it allows for immediate access to the firearm, which can be critical in self-defense situations where milliseconds matter.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →