Self-Defense Handgun Calibers ALL Perform the SAME?

Published on May 18, 2019
Duration: 11:15

This expert analysis debunks the myth that all handgun calibers perform identically in self-defense scenarios. It highlights significant differences in penetration, barrier effectiveness, and incapacitation potential, particularly when encountering bone, clothing, or hard barriers like glass. The video emphasizes that caliber choice and ammunition type are critical for real-world effectiveness, especially against determined threats or when facing obstacles.

Quick Summary

Real-world ballistic tests show that handgun calibers do not all perform the same. Factors like bone, clothing, and barriers such as glass significantly impact bullet effectiveness. More powerful calibers and specialized ammunition like bonded or solid copper rounds offer superior penetration and incapacitation potential compared to weaker calibers and standard lead rounds.

Chapters

  1. 00:12Internet Information & Absolutes
  2. 00:45Handgun Calibers Performance Claims
  3. 01:37Caliber Performance in Real-World Scenarios
  4. 03:02Medical Professional Insights on Calibers
  5. 03:37Hunting and Penetration Differences
  6. 03:49Body Armor and Caliber Effectiveness
  7. 04:21Barriers and Bullet Performance
  8. 05:08Barrier Penetration Comparisons
  9. 05:43Universal Similarity in Self-Defense
  10. 06:07Incapacitation and Determined Threats
  11. 06:30Tissue Damage and Incapacitation
  12. 07:08Circumstance and Caliber Differences
  13. 07:41Round Selection and Barrier Penetration
  14. 08:08Distinguishing Caliber Performance
  15. 08:40Evaluating Tactical Advice

Frequently Asked Questions

Do all handgun calibers perform the same in self-defense?

No, this is a false claim. Real-world scenarios involving barriers like glass, bone, or clothing reveal significant differences in penetration and effectiveness between handgun calibers. Gel tests alone do not accurately represent these complex interactions.

How do different handgun calibers perform against barriers?

Barriers like laminated glass can significantly degrade the performance of rounds like 9mm. Calibers such as 10mm and .40 S&W, especially with bonded ammunition, demonstrate better penetration through laminated glass and metal than weaker rounds like .38 Special.

Can bone stop handgun rounds like 9mm or .380 ACP?

Medical professionals suggest that calibers like .380 ACP and 9mm may be stopped or deflected by bone. In contrast, more powerful calibers like 10mm are described as 'bone blind,' meaning they are less likely to be stopped by bone.

Does ammunition type matter as much as caliber for self-defense?

Yes, ammunition type is crucial. Lead rounds struggle with hard barriers, while solid copper or bonded rounds offer superior penetration through materials like laminated glass and metal, enhancing overall effectiveness.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →