The BIG Problem with Open Carry

Published on August 4, 2025
Duration: 3:46

This video argues that while open carry is a Second Amendment right, it's often a tactically and socially disadvantageous choice. The speaker emphasizes that open carry makes individuals a visible target, forfeits the element of surprise, and can make others uncomfortable, hindering the broader acceptance of an armed society. Concealed carry is presented as the superior method for personal protection when the goal is to blend in and control the timing of engagement.

Quick Summary

Open carry, while a Second Amendment right, presents significant tactical and social disadvantages. It forfeits the element of surprise, makes the carrier a visible target, and can cause discomfort, hindering the broader acceptance of an armed society. Concealed carry is often the smarter choice for self-defense, allowing the carrier to blend in and control engagement timing.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Open Carry Rights vs. Stupidity
  2. 00:13Modern Protector Intro & Topic
  3. 00:21The Social Aspect of Open Carry
  4. 01:04Making Others Uncomfortable
  5. 01:21The Tactical Disadvantage of Open Carry
  6. 01:38Giving Up the Element of Surprise
  7. 01:53Holster Retention and Vulnerability
  8. 02:01Advantage of Concealed Carry
  9. 02:17Open Carry as a Deterrent? (Debunked)
  10. 02:32Becoming Target Number One
  11. 03:06The Blending In Advantage
  12. 03:10Open Carry vs. Concealed Carry: Smart vs. Loud
  13. 03:21Viewer Engagement: Do You Open Carry?
  14. 03:25Next Video Recommendation
  15. 03:33Call to Action: Like & Subscribe
  16. 03:37Closing Remarks & Encouragement

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main tactical disadvantage of open carry?

The primary tactical disadvantage of open carry is the loss of the element of surprise. When your firearm is visible, potential threats know you are armed and can prepare for it or attempt to take it from you, negating a critical advantage in a confrontation.

Why does open carry make individuals a target?

Open carry immediately identifies you as an armed individual. This can make you target number one for criminals who may see you as an immediate threat to neutralize or a source of a weapon to acquire, rather than a deterrent.

How does concealed carry offer an advantage over open carry?

Concealed carry allows you to blend in, maintaining the element of surprise. You control when and if your firearm is revealed, giving you the advantage of timing in a self-defense situation, unlike open carry where your status is immediately known.

Can open carry be a social disadvantage?

Yes, open carry can make people uncomfortable, even in gun-friendly areas. This discomfort can create social friction and may not be conducive to winning over the general public to the idea of an armed society, as it makes the carrier stand out.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Modern Protector

View all →