We Torture Your Favorite Pistols In Mud (Glock, Sig, M&P, Desert Eagle, Staccato, etc)

Published on January 15, 2023
Duration: 32:32

This video details a rigorous mud torture test applied to popular handguns, including Glock, Sig Sauer, Smith & Wesson, and Desert Eagle. Conducted by Garand Thumb, a recognized expert, the test involves submerging firearms in mud and attempting to fire them, followed by an extreme phase of dropping and stepping on the guns. The Sig M18 and Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0 emerged as the most reliable under these harsh conditions.

Quick Summary

The Sig M18 and Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0 demonstrated exceptional reliability by passing Garand Thumb's extreme mud torture test flawlessly. This rigorous test involved submerging firearms in mud and subjecting them to physical stress, simulating harsh real-world conditions.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Scenario
  2. 01:19Testing Procedure
  3. 04:05Initial Mud Tests (Glock, Sig, Beretta, PSA)
  4. 05:50Initial Mud Tests (M&P, CZ, Browning)
  5. 07:11Initial Mud Tests (1911s and HK)
  6. 08:28Initial Mud Tests (Staccato, Walther, Desert Eagle)
  7. 11:20Extreme Mud Test (The Mash Test)
  8. 13:32Final Winners

Frequently Asked Questions

Which handguns performed best in Garand Thumb's mud torture test?

The Sig M18 and Smith & Wesson M&P 2.0 were the only pistols to pass the extreme mud test flawlessly. The Desert Eagle also performed well initially but failed in the final stage.

What was the procedure for the handgun mud torture test?

The test involved firing 5 rounds clean, submerging the pistol in mud, and attempting to fire another 5 rounds. Surviving guns underwent an 'Extreme Mud Test' involving dropping from shoulder height and being stepped on.

Why did some high-end pistols like the Staccato XC fail the mud test?

Pistols with tight tolerances and compensators, such as the Staccato XC, are more prone to malfunctions when heavily fouled with mud, as the debris can interfere with the firearm's cycling and lockup.

What is the significance of the mud torture test for firearm reliability?

The test simulates extreme environmental conditions that could be encountered in self-defense or duty scenarios, highlighting which firearms maintain operational reliability when subjected to severe fouling and stress.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from Garand Thumb

View all →