What if...the US Army adopted Lever Guns in the 1870s?

Published on April 13, 2017
Duration: 13:48

This video explores a hypothetical scenario where the US Army adopted lever-action rifles in the 1870s instead of the single-shot Trapdoor Springfield. It details how a squad might be structured with a squad leader carrying a Winchester 1866, riflemen with Winchester 1876s, and a DMR with a scoped Sharps rifle. The analysis highlights the potential for overwhelming fire superiority and tactical advantages in close-quarters combat, contrasting it with the historical decision and its implications. The discussion is presented with high authority and deep historical and technical knowledge.

Quick Summary

A hypothetical US Army in the 1870s adopting lever-action rifles like the Winchester 1876 could have gained significant fire superiority. This scenario envisions a squad structure with a leader using a Winchester 1866, riflemen with 1876s, and a DMR with a scoped Sharps, offering advantages over the single-shot Trapdoor Springfield.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to the Hypothetical Scenario
  2. 00:44The Historical Choice: Trapdoor Springfield
  3. 03:01Hypothetical Squad Structure: The Squad Leader
  4. 04:37The Standard Rifleman: Winchester 1876
  5. 09:24The DMR Role: Scoped Sharps Rifle
  6. 11:33Tactical Impact and Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What if the US Army adopted lever-action rifles in the 1870s?

A hypothetical US Army in the 1870s adopting lever-action rifles like the Winchester 1876 could have gained significant fire superiority. This scenario envisions a squad structure with a leader using a Winchester 1866, riflemen with 1876s, and a DMR with a scoped Sharps, offering advantages over the single-shot Trapdoor Springfield.

Why did the US Army choose the Trapdoor Springfield over lever-action rifles?

The US Army historically selected the .45-70 Trapdoor Springfield primarily due to concerns about ammunition waste and cost associated with repeaters. This decision, made in the 1870s, prioritized logistical simplicity over the immediate tactical advantages of higher-capacity lever-action firearms.

What role would a Winchester 1876 play in a hypothetical 1870s lever-action US Army?

In a hypothetical 1870s US Army equipped with lever-action rifles, the Winchester 1876 in .45-60 would serve as the standard rifleman's firearm. Its 15+1 capacity and effective range made it a potent weapon, offering substantial fire superiority compared to single-shot rifles of the era.

How could lever-action rifles have changed 19th-century US Army tactics?

The adoption of lever-action rifles would have enabled fire-and-maneuver tactics, providing overwhelming firepower and the ability to reload while advancing. This capability could have been decisive in engagements, offering a significant advantage in close-quarters combat and potentially altering the outcome of conflicts like the Indian Wars.

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from InRangeTV

View all →