Carrying Loaded Guns Safely: Revolver vs. Semi-Auto

Published on August 23, 2011
Duration: 6:55

This guide, based on expert analysis from TheYankeeMarshal, debunks the 'Hair Trigger Fallacy' regarding semi-automatic vs. revolver safety. It details how modern semi-autos and revolvers employ internal safeties that require a deliberate trigger pull, comparing specific trigger weights and emphasizing that safe carry relies on knowledge, proper equipment like holsters, and consistent safe handling habits.

Quick Summary

Expert analysis debunks the 'Hair Trigger Fallacy,' stating modern semi-automatic pistols are as safe to carry loaded as revolvers. Both require a deliberate trigger pull, with internal safeties like firing pin blocks and transfer bars functioning similarly. Safe carry hinges on user knowledge, proper holsters, and consistent safe handling habits, not just firearm type.

Chapters

  1. 00:00The Hair Trigger Fallacy
  2. 01:50Safety Mechanisms Comparison
  3. 03:19Trigger Pull Weights
  4. 04:19Internal Safeties: Firing Pin Blocks and Transfer Bars
  5. 05:26Conclusion and Best Practices

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it safer to carry a loaded revolver or a semi-automatic pistol?

Modern semi-automatic pistols are as safe to carry loaded as revolvers, thanks to internal safeties like firing pin blocks. The 'Hair Trigger Fallacy' is a myth; both firearm types require a deliberate trigger pull to fire, and safe carry depends on user habits and equipment like holsters.

What is the 'Hair Trigger Fallacy' regarding firearm carry?

The 'Hair Trigger Fallacy' is the mistaken belief that a semi-automatic pistol with a cocked striker or hammer is inherently less safe to carry than a double-action revolver with the hammer down. This ignores that both require a trigger pull and modern semi-autos have safeties.

How do safety mechanisms in semi-automatics compare to revolvers?

Modern semi-automatics use firing pin blocks, while revolvers often use transfer bars. Both prevent the firing pin from striking the primer unless the trigger is fully depressed, making them functionally similar in terms of requiring a deliberate trigger pull for discharge.

Are trigger pulls on semi-automatic pistols typically lighter and less safe than revolvers?

No, this is often a misconception. Specific measurements show modern defensive semi-automatics like the Glock 29 (6.8 lbs) and Kahr MK40 (7.2 lbs) have trigger pulls comparable to or lighter than some revolvers (e.g., Colt Revolver at 8.3 lbs).

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →