Challenge Coins & Shooting Standards: Useful or Useless?

Published on September 23, 2025
Duration: 13:36

This video critically examines the practice of issuing challenge coins or patches for passing shooting standards during firearms classes. The instructor argues that these standards often fail to account for the learning curve in a class, where shooting performance may initially decline as students correct bad habits. Instead, he advocates for using standardized drills as self-evaluation tools outside of class time, allowing shooters to identify specific areas for improvement and work on them independently. The focus should be on developing well-rounded skills rather than achieving a single test score.

Quick Summary

Firearms instructor Joel Park argues that shooting standards and challenge coins can be marketing gimmicks that detract from true skill development. He advocates for using standardized drills as self-evaluation tools outside of class, allowing shooters to identify and work on specific weaknesses for more effective, holistic improvement.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Shooting Standards & Challenge Coins
  2. 00:52Why Standards Can Be Problematic
  3. 01:27The Purpose of Taking a Class
  4. 02:27Teaching Students to 'Fish'
  5. 03:19What Makes a Class Helpful
  6. 04:02Instructor's Approach: No Special Drills
  7. 04:16The Marketing Aspect of Standards
  8. 05:21Personal Experience with Standards
  9. 06:12Reasons for Disliking Standards
  10. 06:51What Sparked This Discussion
  11. 07:26An Alternative: Drills in the Wild
  12. 07:45Example: Matt Prana's CQB Warm-up
  13. 09:25Example: Bear Solutions Community Drills
  14. 10:50The Fun of New Drills & Challenges
  15. 11:01Example: Kyle the Four's Speed Bull Drill
  16. 12:13Word of Caution: Don't Let Tests Consume You
  17. 13:10Conclusion & Viewer Thoughts

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are shooting standards and challenge coins often criticized in firearms training?

Critics argue that shooting standards, often tied to challenge coins or patches, can become marketing tools that distract from genuine skill development. Performance may initially decline in class as students correct habits, making these tests unfair. The focus should be on learning to improve, not just passing a single test.

What is the instructor's preferred method for skill evaluation in firearms training?

The instructor advocates for using standardized drills as self-evaluation tools outside of formal classes. These 'out in the wild' drills allow shooters to assess their performance objectively, identify specific areas for improvement, and work on them independently, fostering more holistic skill development.

How can firearms students ensure they are getting the most out of a training class?

Students should focus on identifying actionable takeaways and habits to change during a class, rather than solely aiming to pass a specific test for a reward. The goal is to learn techniques and drills that enable continuous self-improvement after the class concludes.

What are some examples of effective self-assessment drills for shooters?

Examples include Matt Prana's CQB Warm-up, which tests various shooting skills, and drills like the 'Speed Bull' (10 shots on B8 targets in 10 seconds from the draw). These drills help identify specific strengths and weaknesses for targeted practice.

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from Joel Park

View all →