RATE YOUR GUNS LIVE! FIRST OF 2026

Published on February 5, 2026
Duration: 121:06

This episode of 'Rate Your Guns Live!' features a live audience participation segment where viewers submit photos of their firearms for judgment. The hosts and guest judges evaluate each firearm based on aesthetics and perceived quality, classifying them as either 'fire' (highly desirable) or 'water' (undesirable). The session emphasizes that personal preference plays a significant role, but the core criteria revolve around visual appeal and execution of modifications.

Quick Summary

In 'Rate Your Guns Live!', firearms are judged 'fire' or 'water' based on aesthetics and visual appeal. Submissions are evaluated on their overall look, design cohesion, and quality of modifications. 'Fire' signifies a desirable and well-executed firearm, while 'water' indicates it is considered unattractive or poorly modified. Viewers can submit photos via email, but should avoid multiple guns per photo and over-accessorizing.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Live Stream Start
  2. 01:07Explaining the 'Rate Your Guns' Concept for 2026
  3. 01:54Testing the New Poll Feature (Hashtag Fire/Water)
  4. 04:24Testing the Voting Link Feature
  5. 06:50Comparing Hashtag vs. Link Voting Methods
  6. 09:30Discussion on Comfort Shoes (Sketchers vs. New Balance)
  7. 11:03Audience Engagement and Waiting for More Viewers
  8. 13:13Debate on Firearm Aesthetics vs. Comfort
  9. 14:31Rules for Submitting Guns for 'Rate Your Guns'
  10. 17:27Disclaimer: Don't Take Ratings Personally
  11. 18:14Firearm Judging Criteria: Fire or Water Only
  12. 19:37How to Submit Your Firearm Photo via Email
  13. 20:45Ground Rules: No 'Optic Shaming'
  14. 21:24Preparing to Show the First Firearm
  15. 24:21Inviting a New Guest Judge to the Stream
  16. 27:22Introducing Guest Judge Chuck from North Carolina
  17. 29:15Explaining the Judging Process to Guests
  18. 31:17First Firearm: Staccato 2011 with Rose Gold Accents
  19. 34:47Second Firearm: Jacob Gray Knox 9
  20. 35:57Viewer Submits Multiple Guns; Only One Shown
  21. 37:05Third Firearm: Custom Build (Likely a Chassis System)
  22. 39:24Fourth Firearm: MPA (MasterPiece Arms) Build
  23. 41:43Guest Judges' Criteria for Firearm Aesthetics
  24. 42:16Fifth Firearm: Custom Type A Build
  25. 44:00Sixth Firearm: Firearm with Tiger Stripes
  26. 46:14Seventh Firearm: P226 Legion with Shiny Finish
  27. 47:46Eighth Firearm: Ported Pistol (Considered Plain)
  28. 49:16Ninth Firearm: Apollo 11 (Considered Plain)
  29. 50:09Tenth Firearm: Possibly AI-Generated Background
  30. 51:10Eleventh Firearm: Damascus Finish Fusion
  31. 52:22Discussion on Damascus Finish Application (Laser Etching)
  32. 53:07Twelfth Firearm: Rattler with Side-Mounted Light/Laser
  33. 55:41Thirteenth Firearm: Long AR-15 with Suppressor (Considered Plain)
  34. 57:31Fourteenth Firearm: Scar (Considered Ugly/Boxy)
  35. 60:00Fifteenth Firearm: Custom 2011 with Diamond Cut
  36. 62:02Sixteenth Firearm: Modified Prodigy Pistol
  37. 63:04Seventeenth Firearm: Custom 2011 with Rose Gold and Icorus Grip
  38. 64:45Eighteenth Firearm: Dark Forge Pistol (Considered Plain)
  39. 67:03Nineteenth Firearm: Teractical with Keymod Rail (Considered Water)
  40. 70:10Twentieth Firearm: AR-15 with Unusual Handguard/Color
  41. 72:10Twenty-First Firearm: Custom AR-15 with Textured Receiver
  42. 74:03Twenty-Second Firearm: Small Pistol (Considered Water)
  43. 75:24Call to Action: Like the Video and Promote Regular Meetup 6

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the 'Rate Your Guns Live!' segment about?

The 'Rate Your Guns Live!' segment is a live stream event where viewers submit photos of their firearms. Hosts and guests then judge these firearms, classifying them as either 'fire' (highly desirable and aesthetically pleasing) or 'water' (undesirable or poorly executed).

What are the criteria for judging a firearm as 'fire' or 'water'?

The primary criteria are aesthetics, visual appeal, and the perceived quality of modifications. Firearms are judged on their overall look, cohesiveness of design, and execution. 'Too busy,' 'plain,' or 'unfinished' are common reasons for a 'water' rating, while unique designs and clean execution lead to 'fire'.

How can viewers submit their firearms for the 'Rate Your Guns' segment?

Viewers can submit photos of their firearms by emailing them to 'a regular gun guy@gmail.com'. It is recommended to send only one photo per submission and to ensure the photo is high-quality for proper evaluation.

What are some common mistakes to avoid when submitting a firearm for review?

Avoid submitting photos with multiple firearms, as they are difficult to judge individually. Also, refrain from over-accessorizing a firearm without a cohesive theme, as this can lead to it being deemed 'too busy' and receiving a 'water' rating.

What is the significance of the 'fire' vs. 'water' rating system?

The 'fire' vs. 'water' system is a subjective rating based purely on aesthetics and visual appeal. 'Fire' indicates a firearm is considered attractive and well-executed, while 'water' suggests it is not visually appealing or has design flaws. It's meant to be entertaining and subjective, not a definitive quality assessment.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from A REGULAR GUN GUY

View all →