Revolver Showdown: S&W vs. Break Open Webley Revolver - Which Gun is Faster to Reload?

Published on February 27, 2018
Duration: 9:07

This video provides an expert-level comparison of reload speeds between a Smith & Wesson M&P swing-out cylinder revolver and a Webley Mark IV break-open revolver, presented by Mike B. The demonstration includes advanced reload techniques and a timed 12-shot test, revealing nearly identical reload times between the two designs in clean conditions. The Webley's selective ejection and superior leverage for stuck cases are also highlighted.

Quick Summary

Expert Mike B from TFB TV demonstrates that the reload speed between a Smith & Wesson M&P swing-out cylinder and a Webley Mark IV break-open revolver is nearly identical in clean conditions, with both completing a 12-shot test in approximately 15 seconds. The Webley offers unique features like selective ejection and better leverage for stuck cases.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: S&W vs Webley Revolver Comparison
  2. 00:38Mechanical Differences: Swing-Out vs Break-Open Cylinders
  3. 01:22Webley Mark IV Reload Technique Demonstration
  4. 02:04S&W M&P Reload Techniques Explained
  5. 03:42S&W M&P 12-Shot Speed Test Results
  6. 04:59Webley Mark IV 12-Shot Speed Test Results
  7. 06:09Webley's Selective Ejection Feature
  8. 07:46Conclusion: Reload Speed & Final Thoughts

Frequently Asked Questions

Which revolver is faster to reload, the Smith & Wesson M&P or the Webley Mark IV?

In a timed test, the Smith & Wesson M&P and the Webley Mark IV showed nearly identical reload speeds, with the S&W completing a 12-shot sequence in 15.07 seconds and the Webley in 15.68 seconds. Both designs, when used with modern techniques, are very efficient.

What are the key mechanical differences between the S&W M&P and the Webley Mark IV regarding reloading?

The S&W M&P features a swing-out cylinder, while the Webley Mark IV is a break-open design. The Webley offers selective ejection of spent casings and better leverage for stuck cases, whereas the S&W relies on a star extractor for case removal.

Are there specific techniques for reloading revolvers faster?

Yes, advanced techniques like left-hand reloads to keep the muzzle down, or methods popularized by shooters like Jerry Miculek, can significantly improve reload speed. Using speedloaders or speed strips is crucial for efficiency with both swing-out and break-open designs.

What advantages does the Webley Mark IV offer over the S&W M&P in reloading?

The Webley Mark IV excels with its selective ejection, allowing only spent casings to be removed if opened gently. It also provides superior mechanical leverage for extracting stubborn or dirty cases, potentially offering greater reliability in adverse conditions.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from TFB TV

View all →