Smith & Wesson J-Frame M&P340 revolver vs. Glock 36 .45ACP carry pistol

Published on October 30, 2024
Duration: 10:51

This video compares the Smith & Wesson M&P 340 J-Frame revolver and the Glock 36 .45 ACP pistol, emphasizing the critical importance of mastering double-action trigger control for revolvers. The instructor highlights that proficiency with a revolver, especially its heavy double-action trigger, is a 'dying art' and requires significant practice, making it an 'expert's weapon' for many. While semi-automatics offer higher capacity and simpler operation, revolvers can be fired while pressed into an assailant, a key defensive advantage.

Quick Summary

The Smith & Wesson M&P 340 J-Frame (.357 Magnum) and Glock 36 (.45 ACP) represent different concealed carry philosophies. While the Glock offers higher capacity and simpler operation, the M&P 340's ability to fire while pressed into an assailant is a critical defensive advantage. However, mastering the revolver's heavy double-action trigger requires significant practice, making it an 'expert's weapon' for many.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: M&P 340 vs Glock 36
  2. 00:11Calibers and Ammunition
  3. 00:23Safety and Snap Caps
  4. 00:36Capacity Comparison
  5. 00:42Auto vs. Revolver Debate
  6. 00:51Semi-Auto Capacity Advantage
  7. 01:15Pressing into Battery: Revolver Advantage
  8. 01:36M&P 340 Features: Laser Grips
  9. 01:42Grip Customization on Revolvers
  10. 01:55Sights on the M&P 340
  11. 02:07Revolver Trigger Difficulty
  12. 02:16Glock Trigger Weight
  13. 02:24Revolvers as Expert Weapons
  14. 02:54Revolver Trigger Pull Mechanics
  15. 03:06Glock Trigger Mechanics
  16. 03:15Glock Safe Action Trigger
  17. 03:23Double-Action Only vs. Hammered Revolvers
  18. 03:36External Hammer Disadvantages
  19. 03:49Single-Action Shooting Habits
  20. 04:00Importance of Double-Action Proficiency
  21. 04:14Training Recommendation: Double-Action First
  22. 04:32Instructor's Personal Experience
  23. 05:01Running a Revolver in Double-Action
  24. 05:19Revolver Design Limitations
  25. 05:36Semi-Auto Reloading Process
  26. 05:50Revolver Reloading Process
  27. 06:12Reloading Options: Zeta 6 J-Pack
  28. 06:22Carrying Extra Rounds
  29. 06:49Total Capacity with Speed Loader
  30. 06:55Concealable J-Frame Benefits
  31. 07:00M&P 340 vs .357 Magnum
  32. 07:09Ammunition Recommendations
  33. 07:17Favorite Carry J-Frame
  34. 07:20Cylinder Erosion and Flame Cutting
  35. 07:25340PD Considerations
  36. 07:32Frame Material: Scandium Alloy
  37. 07:41Barrel and Frame Construction
  38. 07:45Durability of Finish
  39. 07:52Quality of J-Frame
  40. 07:59Smith & Wesson QC Issues
  41. 08:15Snap Ring Reinstallation
  42. 08:26Smith & Wesson Lockup
  43. 08:32Return Spring Quality
  44. 08:35Running Double-Action Fast
  45. 08:42J-Frame Ease of Use with Practice
  46. 08:47Practice Requirements
  47. 08:54Glock Simplicity vs. J-Frame
  48. 09:08Trigger Ease Comparison
  49. 09:12Glock Safe Action Trigger Explained
  50. 09:31Trigger Reset
  51. 09:41Choosing Between the Two
  52. 09:46Instructor's Preference: J-Frame
  53. 09:58Glock 36 Left-Handed Magazine Release Issue
  54. 10:14Right-Handed Perspective
  55. 10:17Capacity vs. Platform
  56. 10:21Different Weapon Platforms
  57. 10:26Key Considerations for Carry
  58. 10:37Conclusion and Second Amendment Reminder

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Smith & Wesson M&P 340 and the Glock 36 for concealed carry?

The M&P 340 is a J-Frame revolver chambered in .357 Magnum with a 5-round capacity, known for its ability to be fired while pressed into an assailant. The Glock 36 is a semi-automatic pistol in .45 ACP with a 6+1 capacity, offering simpler operation and higher capacity but can go out of battery if pressed.

Why is mastering the double-action trigger on a revolver considered difficult?

Revolvers, especially double-action-only models like the M&P 340, have a significantly heavier and longer trigger pull than most semi-automatic pistols. This requires more strength, control, and practice to manipulate accurately, leading many to consider them 'expert's weapons'.

What are the advantages of a revolver in a close-quarters defensive encounter?

A key advantage of a revolver in close-quarters defense is its ability to be fired even when pressed directly against an attacker. This prevents a semi-automatic pistol from going out of battery, ensuring reliable function when the firearm is in contact with the threat.

How does reloading a revolver compare to reloading a semi-automatic pistol?

Reloading a revolver is generally more time-consuming and requires more manual dexterity. It involves opening the cylinder, ejecting spent casings, and loading each chamber individually. Semi-automatic pistols allow for faster reloads by dropping the magazine and inserting a fresh one.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from BERETTA9mmUSA

View all →