Why Revolvers Are LESS Reliable Than Autos

Published on October 27, 2019
Duration: 9:34

This guide details a simulated test comparing the reliability of a revolver versus a semi-automatic pistol under adverse environmental conditions. The test involves tumbling firearms in lint and burying them in dirt to assess their performance and ease of field maintenance. The findings suggest modern semi-automatic pistols may offer greater reliability in extreme conditions compared to traditional revolvers.

Quick Summary

Expert testing reveals that modern semi-automatic pistols may be more reliable than revolvers in extreme environmental conditions like dirt and sand. While revolvers are simple, their tight tolerances make them prone to complete failure, whereas semi-autos often require only basic field maintenance to restore function after stoppages.

Chapters

  1. 00:00The Revolver Reliability Myth
  2. 00:31Test Setup and Pocket Lint Simulation
  3. 01:11Baseline Performance
  4. 01:35Extreme Dirt and Sand Test
  5. 02:24Revolver Failure Analysis
  6. 04:56Semi-Auto Performance in Dirt
  7. 05:46Field Maintenance Comparison
  8. 07:07Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

Are revolvers less reliable than semi-automatic pistols in harsh conditions?

Testing suggests that while revolvers are simple, their tight tolerances make them more susceptible to total failure from environmental debris like dirt. Semi-automatics, though they may experience malfunctions, are often easier to clear and restore to function with basic field maintenance.

How does pocket lint affect firearm reliability?

According to the test, standard pocket debris like lint and dust, simulated by tumbling firearms in a dryer, did not cause malfunctions in either the tested semi-automatic or revolver, indicating it's not a primary failure point.

What is the 'six for sure' argument regarding revolvers?

The 'six for sure' argument is a common belief that revolvers are inherently more reliable than semi-automatic pistols. However, this video challenges that notion by testing firearms under adverse conditions, suggesting modern semi-autos may perform better in extreme environments.

How easy is it to fix a dirt-contaminated revolver versus a semi-automatic pistol?

Fixing a dirt-contaminated revolver typically requires detailed disassembly to clear internal grit, which is difficult in the field. A semi-automatic pistol, like the S&W M&P Shield tested, could be restored to function with simple field maintenance such as adding lubricant to the slide rails.

Related News

All News →

More Training & Techniques Videos You Might Like

More from TFB TV

View all →