ATF Picks A Fight With Texas Over Suppressor Freedom Law!!!

Published on February 26, 2022
Duration: 9:43

This expert analysis from Armed Scholar details the legal battle initiated by Texas against the ATF concerning HB957, a law aiming to exempt Texas-made suppressors from federal regulation. The state argues that suppressors manufactured and kept within Texas do not fall under interstate commerce and thus are outside federal authority, challenging the NFA and GCA. The lawsuit also questions the constitutionality of federal taxation on items related to the Second Amendment right to bear arms, referencing the Heller decision and demanding strict scrutiny for such regulations.

Quick Summary

Texas is suing the ATF over HB957, a law exempting Texas-made suppressors from federal regulation. The state argues these items are not subject to interstate commerce laws and challenges federal taxation on Second Amendment rights, citing the Heller decision.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Texas Sues ATF Over Suppressor Law
  2. 00:37Details of Texas House Bill 957
  3. 01:05Texas Law Argument Against Regulation
  4. 01:26Federal Law Regulations
  5. 02:12Texas Lawsuit Against the ATF
  6. 02:56Arguments Against Federal Regulation
  7. 03:26Constitutional Rights Arguments
  8. 03:50Strict, Intermediate, Rational Basis Review
  9. 05:11Real Evidence Must Be Presented
  10. 05:51Texas and Federal Regulation
  11. 06:18Effect of Federal Law
  12. 07:04Lawsuit and State Sovereignty
  13. 07:40Advise on Taking Action
  14. 08:37More Info

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Texas House Bill 957?

Texas House Bill 957 is a state law designed to exempt suppressors manufactured and kept within Texas from federal firearms regulations, including NFA registration. It requires these suppressors to be stamped 'Made in Texas'.

Why is Texas suing the ATF?

Texas sued the ATF to prevent federal enforcement of NFA and GCA regulations against suppressors made and sold within the state. Texas argues these items are not subject to federal regulation as they do not involve interstate commerce.

What are the constitutional arguments against federal suppressor regulation?

Texas argues that federal taxation and regulation of suppressors made for personal use within the state violate the Second Amendment. They contend these regulations fail intermediate and strict scrutiny and that federal taxation on constitutional rights is not justified.

What is the ATF's stance on Texas-made suppressors?

The ATF has indicated it will prosecute individuals involved with 'Made in Texas' suppressors, threatening enforcement of NFA and GCA regulations. This has led Texas to file a lawsuit to challenge the ATF's authority.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Armed Scholar

View all →