Ben Shapiro Compromises on Second Amendment

Published on August 9, 2022
Duration: 5:49

This video critiques Ben Shapiro's stance on fully automatic weapons, arguing that Americans should have the right to own them. It explains the National Firearms Act (NFA) and the impact of the 1986 Hughes Amendment, which restricted civilian ownership of machine guns manufactured after that date. The video asserts that the Second Amendment protects the right to own dangerous tools for resisting tyranny, citing historical precedents and recent Supreme Court rulings like Bruen.

Quick Summary

Civilians can legally own machine guns in most US states if they were manufactured before May 19, 1986, and are registered under the National Firearms Act (NFA). This process requires a federal tax stamp and typically costs over $10,000. The Hughes Amendment of 1986 prohibited the registration of newly manufactured automatic weapons for civilian use.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Ben Shapiro's Stance
  2. 00:19Shapiro's Argument on Machine Guns
  3. 00:52The Case for Legalizing Full Auto
  4. 01:21How Civilians Can Buy Machine Guns
  5. 01:35The National Firearms Act (NFA)
  6. 01:45The Hughes Amendment Explained
  7. 02:07Civilian Ownership Post-Hughes Amendment
  8. 02:18Debunking 'Inherently Dangerous'
  9. 02:34Bruen v. New York and 2A Rights
  10. 02:55Historical Precedent for Ownership
  11. 03:18Firearm Functionality vs. Mass Shootings
  12. 03:38The Danger of Compromise on 2A
  13. 03:46Machine Guns as Tools Against Tyranny
  14. 04:09Addressing Low Numbers vs. Danger
  15. 04:12ATF Data on Registered Machine Guns
  16. 04:30Source of Confiscated Full Autos
  17. 04:50Robust History of Ownership
  18. 04:57The Gatling Gun Precedent
  19. 05:05Frustration with Accepting Opponent's Premises
  20. 05:20Keeping Rights Because They Are Dangerous
  21. 05:28Gun Owners of America's Stance

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Hughes Amendment and how does it affect machine gun ownership?

The Hughes Amendment, enacted in 1986, prohibited the registration of any machine guns manufactured after May 19, 1986, for civilian ownership. This effectively ended the legal transfer of newly manufactured automatic weapons to the general public, though pre-1986 registered machine guns remain transferable.

Can civilians legally own machine guns in the US?

Yes, civilians can legally own machine guns in most US states, provided they are registered under the National Firearms Act (NFA) and were manufactured before May 19, 1986. This process involves a federal tax stamp, background checks, and significant cost, typically over $10,000.

What is the legal basis for owning potentially dangerous firearms like machine guns?

The argument for owning potentially dangerous firearms rests on the Second Amendment's protection of the right to bear arms for self-defense and to resist tyranny. Recent Supreme Court rulings, like Bruen v. New York, emphasize that restrictions on these rights must be historically justified, making it difficult to ban arms like machine guns based solely on their perceived danger.

How does the number of legally owned machine guns relate to crime statistics?

The video highlights that the number of homicides committed with legally owned machine guns is extremely low, under 10 since the 1930s. It suggests that the functionality of firearms does not directly correlate with mass shooting incidents, and that criminal acquisition of automatic weapons typically occurs through illegal channels, not legal purchases.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Gun Owners of America

View all →