Biden Administration Files Supreme Court Brief AGAINST 2nd Amendment

Published on September 22, 2021
Duration: 14:20

This video discusses the Biden administration's amicus brief filed with the Supreme Court in the New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. Bruin case. The brief argues against the Second Amendment rights of individuals seeking concealed carry permits in New York, specifically challenging the 'proper cause' requirement. The speaker expresses strong disapproval of the administration's stance, interpreting it as an attempt to undermine constitutional rights and uphold restrictive gun laws.

Quick Summary

The Biden administration has filed an amicus brief with the Supreme Court in the NYSRPA v. Bruin case, arguing against Second Amendment rights for concealed carry in New York. The brief supports New York's 'proper cause' requirement, which demands applicants prove a specific need for self-defense beyond simply invoking their constitutional rights.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Special Live Edition
  2. 00:20Biden Administration Files Amicus Brief
  3. 00:30NYSRPA v. Bruin Case Overview
  4. 01:00Brief's Stance: Throw Out the Case
  5. 01:1542-Page Brief Discussion
  6. 01:40New York's Licensing Laws
  7. 02:00Question Presented: Self-Defense Rights
  8. 02:29Summary of Argument: Defending Federal Laws
  9. 02:50New York's Prohibition Since 1911
  10. 03:14Premises vs. Carry Licenses
  11. 04:07Summary of Argument: Proper Cause Requirement
  12. 04:13New York's Proper Cause Explained
  13. 05:13Second Amendment Not Absolute
  14. 06:11Text, History, and Tradition
  15. 06:18Heller Decision Impact
  16. 07:18New Measures and Intermediate Scrutiny
  17. 08:02Strict vs. Intermediate Scrutiny
  18. 09:43Federal Law as Precedent
  19. 10:25New York's Proper Cause Constitutional?
  20. 11:04New York's Law Tradition
  21. 11:15Satisfying Intermediate Scrutiny
  22. 12:11President's Stance Criticized
  23. 12:41Case Outlook and Timeline
  24. 13:00Future Videos and Call to Action
  25. 13:53Closing Remarks and Safety

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the significance of the Biden administration filing an amicus brief in the NYSRPA v. Bruin case?

The Biden administration's amicus brief to the Supreme Court in NYSRPA v. Bruin is significant because it argues against Second Amendment rights for concealed carry in New York. This stance is interpreted by the speaker as an attempt to uphold restrictive gun laws and undermine constitutional protections for firearm ownership.

What is New York's 'proper cause' requirement for concealed carry licenses?

New York's 'proper cause' requirement mandates that individuals applying for a concealed carry permit must demonstrate a specific, demonstrable need for self-defense. Simply asserting Second Amendment rights is insufficient; applicants must prove they face a heightened risk that necessitates carrying a firearm in public.

How does the Biden administration's brief interpret the Second Amendment according to the video?

According to the video's interpretation of the Biden administration's amicus brief, the Second Amendment protects an individual right to keep and bear arms, but this right is not absolute. The brief suggests that a wide range of gun regulations are permissible and supported by historical tradition.

What is intermediate scrutiny in the context of Second Amendment cases?

Intermediate scrutiny is a legal standard where courts assess if a law serves an important government objective and is substantially related to achieving it. The speaker criticizes this standard as a tool used to uphold gun control measures by balancing public safety against individual rights, arguing it's a less rigorous test than strict scrutiny.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Guns & Gadgets 2nd Amendment News

View all →