BIG MISTAKE! Anti-Gunners ACCIDENTALLY Prove THEY CAN'T BAN AR-15s...

Published on April 1, 2023
Duration: 16:58

This video argues that anti-gun advocates' own statements, particularly those published by the Washington Post and NBC, inadvertently prove that AR-15s and similar semi-automatic rifles are in 'common use' in the United States. This 'common use' status, as established by the Supreme Court in Heller v. District of Columbia, is the critical legal standard that prevents these firearms from being banned. The speaker, a constitutional attorney, emphasizes that the 'need' for such firearms is irrelevant under Second Amendment law; what matters is their widespread ownership and use by law-abiding citizens.

Quick Summary

The Second Amendment protects firearms in 'common use,' as established by the Supreme Court in Heller v. District of Columbia. Anti-gun advocates' own statements, particularly those from the Washington Post and NBC, often highlight the AR-15's widespread ownership and popularity, inadvertently proving it is in 'common use' and thus protected from bans. The 'need' for the firearm is legally irrelevant; its protected status stems from its commonality.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Anti-Gunners Can't Ban AR-15s
  2. 00:16Host Introduction: Mark Smith, Constitutional Attorney
  3. 00:30Washington Post Exposes on AR-15s
  4. 00:58The Irrelevance of 'Need' vs. 'Entitlement'
  5. 01:39Heller v. District of Columbia and Handguns
  6. 02:22Supreme Court: 'Whatever the Reason' Matters
  7. 03:28Rationale Applies to AR-15 Bans
  8. 04:08Bill of Rights, Not Bill of Needs
  9. 04:18Anti-Gunners' Mistake: Proving 'Common Use'
  10. 04:44The 'Common Use' Test Explained
  11. 05:11Can Semi-Automatic Rifles Be Banned? No.
  12. 05:43Evidence of AR-15 Common Use
  13. 06:25ATF Filings on AR-15 Popularity
  14. 06:50Hoisting Anti-Gunners on Their Own Petard
  15. 07:45Washington Post Quotes on AR-15 Ubiquity
  16. 10:17NBC News 2017: AR-15 Irreversibly Lodged in Culture
  17. 11:13Addressing 'Shrewd Marketing' Claims
  18. 13:37Demand Dictates Product Success
  19. 14:15More Anti-Gun Quotes for the Record
  20. 14:35Rep. Eric Swalwell on Ubiquitous Rifles
  21. 15:09NEA on Military-Style Weapons
  22. 15:32Mother Jones on 'Saturated' Assault Weapons
  23. 15:50Conclusion: Common Use Means Cannot Be Banned
  24. 16:33Final Thoughts and Call to Subscribe

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the legal basis for preventing AR-15 bans in the US?

The legal basis is the Second Amendment, specifically the Supreme Court's interpretation in Heller v. District of Columbia. This ruling established that firearms in 'common use' for lawful purposes, like self-defense, are protected and cannot be banned. Anti-gun advocates' own admissions of the AR-15's ubiquity serve as evidence of this common use.

Why is the 'need' for an AR-15 irrelevant in legal arguments?

According to constitutional attorney Mark Smith, the 'need' for a firearm is irrelevant under the Second Amendment. The Supreme Court in Heller stated that 'whatever the reason' Americans choose a firearm for self-defense, it is protected. The focus is on the right to keep and bear arms, not on justifying individual necessity.

How do statements from sources like the Washington Post help gun rights advocates?

Statements from sources like the Washington Post, which highlight the AR-15 as the best-selling rifle and mention millions of owners, inadvertently provide evidence for the 'common use' test. This data, published by entities often seen as pro-gun control, can be used in legal and public discourse to demonstrate that AR-15s are widely owned and therefore protected by the Second Amendment.

Can 'shrewd marketing' by the gun industry explain the AR-15's popularity?

No, according to the speaker. While marketing plays a role, the ultimate success and widespread adoption of a product like the AR-15 are driven by public demand. If consumers didn't want the product, even extensive marketing would fail, as seen with failed ventures like CNN+.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from The Four Boxes Diner

View all →