BREAKING NEWS: FEDERAL JUDGES SCREW UP MAJORLY (AGAIN...)

Published on August 29, 2025
Duration: 17:41

This video analyzes a recent Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals decision in United States v. Peterson concerning the regulation of suppressors under the National Firearms Act (NFA). The speaker argues the panel made significant errors by conflating NFA taxation and registration schemes with 'shall-issue' licensing regimes, citing Supreme Court precedent and Justice Kavanaugh's dissents to highlight why suppressors, as protected arms, cannot be subject to targeted taxes or registration requirements.

Quick Summary

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, in US v. Peterson, ruled that suppressors are protected arms under the Second Amendment but upheld the NFA's taxation and registration requirements. The speaker criticizes this by arguing the court wrongly conflated NFA regulations with 'shall-issue' licensing, citing precedent that prohibits targeted taxes on constitutional rights and registration of protected arms.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Breaking News: Fifth Circuit's Suppressor Case Error
  2. 01:00Introduction: Mark Smith, The Four Boxes Diner
  3. 01:12The Fifth Circuit's Mess-Up in US v. Peterson
  4. 02:03Second Amendment Text and Suppressors as Arms
  5. 03:07The Panel Revokes Prior Opinion
  6. 03:49New Opinion: Suppressors are Arms, But NFA Still Applies?
  7. 05:24The Panel's Flawed Analysis of NFA Constitutionality
  8. 06:15Conflating NFA with Shall-Issue Licensing Regimes
  9. 07:01NFA is Taxation and Registration, Not Licensing
  10. 08:07Why the NFA Tax is Still Relevant in Peterson Case
  11. 08:34Justice Kavanaugh's Distinction: Licensing vs. Registration
  12. 10:01Kavanaugh: Registration Laws vs. Licensing Laws
  13. 11:16Licensing vs. NFA Registration/Taxation Scheme
  14. 12:15Consequences: Suppressors as Protected Arms
  15. 12:22Cannot Tax Protected Arms: Harper v. Board of Elections
  16. 13:26Reaction to the Fifth Circuit's Opinion
  17. 13:43Registration Scheme Not Justified by Licensing Precedents
  18. 14:31Final Nail: Registration of Protected Arms is Illegal
  19. 14:45Kavanaugh on Registration of Protected Arms
  20. 15:08US v. Miller and Registration Requirements
  21. 16:05If an Arm is Protected, It Cannot Be Registered or Taxed
  22. 16:48Fifth Circuit's Failure to Analyze Precedent
  23. 17:15Conclusion and Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the Fifth Circuit's ruling in United States v. Peterson regarding suppressors?

The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that suppressors can be regulated under the National Firearms Act (NFA), including its taxation and registration requirements, deeming these constitutional under the Second Amendment. This decision reversed their earlier stance that suppressors were not protected arms.

Why does the speaker believe the Fifth Circuit's ruling on NFA regulations is flawed?

The speaker argues the Fifth Circuit wrongly conflated the NFA's taxation and registration scheme with 'shall-issue' licensing regimes. They cite Justice Kavanaugh's dissent in Heller 2, which distinguishes between licensing and registration, and Supreme Court precedent like Harper v. Board of Elections, which prohibits targeted taxes on constitutional rights.

Are suppressors considered protected arms under the Second Amendment according to the Fifth Circuit's latest ruling?

Yes, in their latest opinion in United States v. Peterson, the Fifth Circuit panel assumed for the purposes of the ruling that suppressors are arms protected by the Second Amendment. However, they still upheld the NFA's regulatory framework.

What is the significance of the $200 tax under the National Firearms Act in the Peterson case?

The $200 tax is relevant because George Peterson was indicted under the old version of the NFA for possessing a suppressor without registering it or paying the tax. The speaker argues that as suppressors are now considered protected arms, such a targeted tax is unconstitutional.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from The Four Boxes Diner

View all →