California: NRA / CRPA Foundation Lawsuit Challenging San Diego County's CCW Policies

Published on May 27, 2011
Duration: 6:06

This video discusses the Peruta case, a lawsuit challenging San Diego County's concealed carry permit policies. The NRA and CRPA Foundation filed an opening brief with the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. The core argument is that the Second Amendment right to bear arms extends to carrying firearms in public for self-defense, and that unloaded open carry is an insufficient accommodation. The case also touches on the Fourteenth Amendment's incorporation of the Second Amendment.

Quick Summary

The Peruta case challenges San Diego County's concealed carry permit policies, arguing the Second Amendment right to bear arms includes public carry for self-defense. The Ninth Circuit is reviewing the appeal, which contests the adequacy of unloaded open carry as a remedy, citing historical context of the Fourteenth Amendment.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and California Legal Landscape
  2. 00:27Peruta Case Lawsuit Overview
  3. 00:39Opening Brief Filed with 9th Circuit
  4. 00:46Amicus Briefs Filed by CORE
  5. 00:53Peruta Case: Challenging San Diego CCW Policy
  6. 01:08Second Amendment Right to Carry in Public
  7. 01:29District Court Ruling on Unloaded Open Carry
  8. 02:05Appeal to the Ninth Circuit
  9. 02:11Arguments Presented to the Ninth Circuit
  10. 02:36Critique of Unloaded Open Carry as Remedy
  11. 03:51Legal Standards: Heller and Nordyke
  12. 04:28CORE Brief: 14th Amendment and Public Carry
  13. 05:01Conclusion and Resources

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Peruta case about?

The Peruta case is a lawsuit challenging San Diego County's policies regarding concealed carry permits. The NRA and CRPA Foundation argue that the sheriff's refusal to issue permits for self-defense violates Second Amendment rights, as the right to bear arms includes carrying firearms in public.

What is the main legal argument in the Peruta case appeal?

The core argument is that the Second Amendment right to bear arms extends to carrying firearms in public for self-defense. The appeal challenges the district court's ruling that unloaded open carry is an adequate accommodation, deeming it impractical and insufficient for self-defense.

What role does the Fourteenth Amendment play in the Peruta case?

An amicus brief filed by the Congress of Racial Equality highlights the historical context of the Fourteenth Amendment. It argues that the amendment's purpose and its incorporation of the Second Amendment clearly indicate that the right to bear arms applies outside the home.

Where can I find legal documents for the Peruta case?

Legal documents and updates for the Peruta case are available on the Michelle Lawyers website, often found at michelleawyers.com/peruda. You can also find information on the CRPA Foundation website.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from NRA

View all →