Cops Took His Guns Over His Wife's Mental Health

Published on November 9, 2025
Duration: 14:51

This video details a New Jersey man's lawsuit against the state after his firearms were confiscated due to his wife's involuntary psychiatric commitment. The speaker, a former therapist, critically analyzes the legal proceedings, highlighting alleged violations of due process and privacy, and discusses relevant New Jersey statutes concerning firearm return. The case involves the Second Amendment Foundation and NJFOS, alleging constitutional infringements.

Quick Summary

A New Jersey man, Elsid Aliaj, is suing the state after his firearms were confiscated following his wife's involuntary psychiatric hold. The Bergen County Prosecutor's Office refused to return his guns, citing a 'duty to warn' statute, despite the absence of an ERPO. Aliaj alleges violations of the Second and Fourteenth Amendments.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: NJ Man Sues Over Gun Confiscation
  2. 02:54Incident Background: Wife's Psychiatric Hold
  3. 04:32Firearms Confiscation Without Warrant
  4. 06:06Legal Obstruction: Prosecutor's Refusal
  5. 07:55Statutory Analysis: Firearm Return Law
  6. 09:04Prosecutor's Demands: Medical Records
  7. 10:58Mental Health Context: Adjustment Disorder
  8. 12:43Constitutional Violations Lawsuit

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did Elsid Aliaj's guns get confiscated in New Jersey?

Elsid Aliaj's firearms were confiscated after his wife underwent an involuntary 3-day psychiatric hold. Although the hold was reportedly due to a misunderstanding and not a risk of self-harm, the Bergen County Prosecutor's Office refused to return his legally owned guns, citing a 'duty to warn' statute.

What New Jersey law pertains to returning firearms after a psychiatric hold?

N.J.S.A. 2A:62A-16.1.e is a New Jersey statute that requires the immediate return of firearms to a legal owner if they are not owned by the patient and the owner attests the patient lacks access. This law was cited as being potentially violated in Elsid Aliaj's case.

What legal action is being taken regarding the confiscated firearms?

Elsid Aliaj has filed a lawsuit, supported by the Second Amendment Foundation and NJFOS, alleging violations of his Second and Fourteenth Amendment rights, as well as state laws. The suit challenges the confiscation and refusal to return his firearms.

Did the police have a warrant to seize Elsid Aliaj's firearms?

According to the video, police arrived at Elsid Aliaj's home and demanded his firearms without a warrant or court order, threatening arrest. He subsequently surrendered his rifle, handguns, magazines, and ammunition under duress.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Liberty Doll

View all →