Ginny Simone Reporting | S5 E13: "Justice in New Jersey?"

Published on August 7, 2014
Duration: 8:16

This video details the legal challenges faced by Chenine Allen, who was arrested in New Jersey for illegally carrying a firearm despite holding a valid concealed carry permit from Pennsylvania. The case highlights the strict and non-reciprocal gun laws in New Jersey, where a legal permit from another state is not recognized. Allen's attempts to have her case dismissed via a firearm amnesty or enter a Pre-Trial Intervention (PTI) program were denied, leading to a trial. The narrative emphasizes the perceived injustice and the potential for law-abiding citizens to be criminalized by state-specific firearm regulations, advocating for national carry reciprocity.

Quick Summary

New Jersey does not recognize concealed carry permits from other states, meaning a valid Pennsylvania CCW permit is not sufficient to legally carry a firearm in NJ. Chenine Allen was arrested and denied Pre-Trial Intervention (PTI) despite this, highlighting the state's strict gun laws and the need for national reciprocity.

Chapters

  1. 00:06Introduction: Chenine Allen's Arrest
  2. 00:19Court Proceedings and Denied Motions
  3. 00:52Critique of New Jersey's Gun Laws
  4. 01:15Chenine Allen's Background and Motivation
  5. 01:55The Traffic Stop and Arrest
  6. 02:39Initial Thoughts During the Stop
  7. 02:51Detention and Booking Process
  8. 03:24Reason for Arrest Explained
  9. 03:47Jail Time and PA License Invalidation
  10. 03:55New Jersey's Stance on Firearms
  11. 04:08The Judge's Ruling and Truth
  12. 04:18Advice: Don't Talk to Police
  13. 04:28Assemblyman Greenwald and Magazine Ban
  14. 04:42Denial of Pre-Trial Intervention (PTI)
  15. 05:02Comparison: Ray Rice and PTI
  16. 05:21Discretion in Criminal Cases
  17. 05:30Call for Second Chances
  18. 05:33Luddite: Fear of Firearms
  19. 05:45Prosecutor's Past Philosophy
  20. 06:08Common Sense and PTI
  21. 06:26Prosecution's Motives
  22. 06:33Other Cases in the County
  23. 06:43The Solution: Stop Arresting Citizens
  24. 06:48Impact on Chenine's Life
  25. 06:55Loss of Rights and Need for Reciprocity
  26. 07:18Federal Intervention Needed
  27. 07:22Why National Reciprocity is Crucial
  28. 07:33Goal: No Felony Record
  29. 07:42Hope for Resolution
  30. 07:46An Honest Mistake for All
  31. 08:01Conclusion: Justice for Chenine
  32. 08:07New Jersey's Gun Laws Out of Control

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Pennsylvania concealed carry permit be used in New Jersey?

No, New Jersey does not recognize concealed carry permits from other states. Individuals must obtain a separate New Jersey permit to legally carry a firearm within the state, regardless of their out-of-state licensing.

What is Pre-Trial Intervention (PTI) in New Jersey?

Pre-Trial Intervention (PTI) is a program in New Jersey designed for first-time offenders facing non-violent charges. Successful completion typically results in the dismissal of charges and avoids a criminal record, but it is subject to prosecutorial discretion.

Why was Chenine Allen arrested in New Jersey?

Chenine Allen was arrested in New Jersey for illegally carrying a firearm. Despite holding a valid concealed carry permit from Pennsylvania, New Jersey law requires a separate state permit, and her out-of-state permit was not recognized.

What is the proposed solution to inconsistent state gun laws?

The video advocates for National Carry Reciprocity, a federal law that would require all states to recognize concealed carry permits issued by any other state, aiming to create uniform gun rights across the country.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from NRA

View all →