Left tying Texas abortion law to Gun Control?... calls for lawsuits for any gun sale in Left states

Published on September 13, 2021
Duration: 5:42

This video discusses a legal strategy proposed by Alan Dershowitz, suggesting that liberal states could apply the Texas abortion bounty law's civil lawsuit model to gun sales. The speaker analyzes why this tactic is unlikely to succeed, highlighting the constitutional protections of the Second Amendment and existing federal laws like the PLCAA, which protect firearm commerce.

Quick Summary

A proposed legal strategy suggests liberal states could use a civil lawsuit bounty system, modeled on Texas's abortion law, to deter gun sales. However, this tactic is unlikely to succeed due to the strong constitutional protections of the Second Amendment and existing federal laws like the PLCAA, which shield firearm commerce.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Spicy Legal Tactic
  2. 00:51Article Title: Applying Abortion Law to Gun Sales
  3. 01:12Abortion & Gun Control: Controversial Issues
  4. 01:36Texas Abortion Law Explained
  5. 02:32The 'Good for the Goose' Approach
  6. 03:34Out-of-the-Box Proposal: Gun Control Lawsuits
  7. 04:10Why This Tactic Won't Work
  8. 04:28Second Amendment vs. Abortion Rights
  9. 04:53Impact of PLCAA on Gun Commerce
  10. 05:23Apples and Oranges: Different Legal Animals
  11. 05:32Conclusion & Viewer Thoughts

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the proposed legal strategy linking Texas's abortion law to gun control?

The strategy suggests liberal states could adopt a civil lawsuit bounty system, similar to Texas's approach to its abortion law, to deter gun sales. This would empower private citizens to sue individuals who facilitate the sale or ownership of firearms.

Why might the Texas abortion law's civil lawsuit model be applied to gun control?

The Texas law allows private citizens to sue those facilitating abortions after six weeks. Proponents of the gun control strategy believe a similar mechanism could be used to sue individuals involved in gun sales, creating a deterrent effect.

What are the main arguments against applying the Texas abortion law model to gun control?

The primary arguments are the explicit constitutional protection of the Second Amendment, which is seen as stronger than abortion rights, and existing federal laws like the PLCAA that protect firearm commerce and manufacturers from certain lawsuits.

How does the Second Amendment differ from abortion rights in this legal context?

The speaker distinguishes between a 'constitutionally protected right' and a 'constitutionally insured right.' The Second Amendment is presented as 'shall not be infringed,' implying a more direct and robust constitutional guarantee than abortion, which is not explicitly enumerated in the Constitution.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Langley Outdoors Academy

View all →