Los Angeles City Council Unwittingly Invites Legal Challenge to City's Restrictive CCW Policy

Published on February 24, 2011
Duration: 6:26

The Los Angeles City Council's attempt to ban open carry is facing legal challenges due to the Peruta case ruling. This ruling suggests that banning both open and concealed carry in public violates Second Amendment rights. If LA bans open carry, it may be compelled to issue concealed weapon permits based on self-defense claims, potentially overriding California's high 'good cause' standard.

Quick Summary

The Los Angeles City Council's proposed ban on open carry is facing significant legal hurdles due to the Peruta case ruling. This ruling implies that banning both open and concealed carry in public infringes upon Second Amendment rights. If LA proceeds with the open-carry ban, it may be legally compelled to issue concealed weapon permits based on self-defense claims, potentially overriding California's stringent 'good cause' requirements.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to LA's Open Carry Ban Delay
  2. 00:19Curiouser and Curiouser: Council's Hesitation
  3. 00:24Urgency Motion and Skipped Review Process
  4. 00:56Realization: Opening a Can of Worms
  5. 01:13Legal Ramifications: Compelled CCW Issuance
  6. 01:21The Peruta Case Explained
  7. 02:03Peruta Court's Reasoning on Second Amendment Rights
  8. 02:36Critique of Unloaded Open Carry
  9. 02:40LA's Ban and the Path to CCW Lawsuits
  10. 03:03California's High 'Good Cause' Standard for CCW
  11. 03:18Advocating for Self-Defense as Good Cause
  12. 03:29Lawsuit Setup: Forcing CCW Issuance
  13. 03:49NRA/CRPA's Long-Term Strategy
  14. 04:12Watching Them Twist in the Wind
  15. 04:16Sacramento's Interest and Ramifications
  16. 04:28Gun Control Advocates Tying Themselves in Knots
  17. 04:47Spinning the Message: Public Safety vs. Reality
  18. 05:07Letting the Ban Die?
  19. 05:09The Simple Solution: Issue CCW Permits
  20. 05:22Upcoming Lawsuit Against LA City
  21. 05:30Consent Decree and Good Faith Evaluations
  22. 05:41Back to Old Habits: Discouraging Applications
  23. 06:00Work Cut Out for LA and San Francisco
  24. 06:07Concluding Remarks and Future Updates

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is the Los Angeles City Council delaying its ban on open carry?

The Los Angeles City Council is delaying its ban on open carry because they have realized that banning this option could legally compel them to issue concealed weapon permits. This is due to the Peruta case ruling, which suggests that banning both open and concealed carry in public may violate Second Amendment rights.

What is the Peruta case and how does it relate to CCW permits in Los Angeles?

The Peruta case in San Diego established that the Second Amendment right to carry a firearm in public is satisfied if either open or concealed carry is permitted, but not if both are banned. If Los Angeles bans open carry, it leaves concealed carry as the only option, potentially forcing the city to issue permits based on self-defense claims, challenging California's strict 'good cause' requirements.

What is the historical 'good cause' standard for concealed weapon permits in California?

Historically, California has required a high standard for 'good cause' to issue a concealed weapon permit, typically demanding an articulable threat of death or stalking. Advocates argue this standard is too restrictive and that a simple declaration of self-defense should suffice, especially if open carry is banned.

Are there other legal challenges against Los Angeles's CCW policies?

Yes, in addition to the potential challenge stemming from the open-carry ban, Los Angeles is facing another lawsuit for allegedly failing to comply with a consent decree. This decree mandates good faith evaluations of concealed weapon permit applications, and critics claim the city is reverting to old tactics of discouraging applications.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from NRA

View all →