MAJOR BREAKING NEWS: BIDEN APPOINTED JUDGES HAND US GREAT 2A WIN!

Published on April 10, 2025
Duration: 12:32

This video discusses a significant Second Amendment victory in the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit, where Biden-appointed judges denied Maine's Attorney General's motion to stay a preliminary injunction against a 72-hour waiting period for firearm purchases. The court found that the state did not make a strong enough showing to overturn the lower court's decision, which had preliminarily enjoined the law based on a likely Second Amendment violation under the Bruen standard. The speaker, Mark W. Smith, a Constitutional Attorney and 'Top Voice of 2A', highlights the rarity of such a win in the typically anti-gun First Circuit.

Quick Summary

A major Second Amendment victory was secured as the First Circuit Court of Appeals, comprised of Biden-appointed judges, denied Maine's motion to reinstate a 72-hour firearm waiting period. This upholds a preliminary injunction that found the waiting period likely violated Second Amendment rights under the Bruen standard, marking a rare win in a historically anti-gun circuit.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Major 2A win in Boston
  2. 00:23Speaker Introduction and Credentials
  3. 00:36First Circuit: Anti-Gun History
  4. 01:01Maine 72-Hour Waiting Period Injunction
  5. 01:56Case Background: Beckwith v. Frey
  6. 02:54Biden-Appointed Judges Deny Stay
  7. 03:47Court Order Excerpt
  8. 04:42Implications of First Circuit Decision
  9. 06:30Rarity of 2A Win in First Circuit
  10. 07:37Judge Walker's Rationale: Right to Acquire
  11. 09:05First Amendment Analogy and Historical Test
  12. 11:20Injunction Stands, Good News

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the recent Second Amendment victory discussed in the video?

A significant Second Amendment victory occurred when the First Circuit Court of Appeals denied Maine's Attorney General's motion to stay a preliminary injunction against the state's 72-hour firearm waiting period. This means the injunction blocking the waiting period remains in effect.

Who are the key figures involved in the Beckwith v. Frey case?

The case involves Maine Attorney General Aaron Frey, who appealed the preliminary injunction. The injunction was initially granted by Trump-appointed Judge Lance Walker and upheld by a panel of Biden-appointed judges on the First Circuit Court of Appeals.

What is the significance of the First Circuit Court of Appeals in this ruling?

The First Circuit is noted for being historically anti-gun. The fact that Biden-appointed judges on this court denied the state's motion to reinstate the waiting period is considered a rare and significant win for Second Amendment advocates.

What legal standard was applied in the Beckwith v. Frey case?

The district court found the plaintiffs were likely to succeed on the merits of their Second Amendment challenge under the standard set forth in New York State Rifle & Pistol Ass'n, Inc. v. Bruen, 597 U.S. 1 (2022). The First Circuit panel did not find the state made a strong enough showing to overturn this.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from The Four Boxes Diner

View all →