NICS Error Sends Gun Owner to Jail in Florida

Published on June 8, 2026
Duration: 9:14

This video details a case where a Florida gun owner, William Brewer, was jailed for 14 days due to a false denial by the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS). The incident highlights issues with NICS accuracy, the impact of legislation like the NICS Denial Notification Act and Fix NICS Act, and the disproportionate effect on minority groups. Gun Owners of America (GOA) is advocating for reforms, including the abolition of the NICS system.

Quick Summary

A Florida gun owner was jailed for 14 days due to a false denial by the NICS system, stemming from an old misdemeanor. This incident highlights concerns about NICS accuracy, exacerbated by laws like the NICS Denial Notification Act. Gun Owners of America is advocating for the abolition of the NICS system due to its high rate of false positives and minimal impact on actual crime.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Florida Gun Owner Jailed by NICS Error
  2. 00:20GOA's GOALS Convention Announcement
  3. 00:42The Case of William Brewer: False NICS Denial
  4. 01:03How the NICS Denial Notification Act Contributed
  5. 01:21Fix NICS Act and System Maintenance Issues
  6. 01:36NICS Accuracy Claims vs. Reality
  7. 01:46William Brewer's Personal Account
  8. 03:07Florida's Legal Holds and Attempts to Create a Felony Charge
  9. 03:36Prosecutors Dropping Charges and Brewer Suing
  10. 03:50Thomas Massie's NICS Data Reporting Act
  11. 04:07Dr. John Lott on NICS System Failures
  12. 04:16NICS Denials vs. Convictions Statistics
  13. 04:34Historical Enforcement Efforts and Their Failures
  14. 04:54Disproportionate Impact on Minorities
  15. 05:37GOA's Advocacy for NICS Abolition

Frequently Asked Questions

Why was a Florida gun owner jailed due to a NICS error?

A Florida gun owner, William Brewer, was jailed for 14 days because the National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS) falsely denied his firearm purchase. This occurred due to a 10-year-old misdemeanor in Kentucky being incorrectly flagged, leading to his arrest despite being a law-abiding citizen with a concealed carry permit.

What is the NICS Denial Notification Act and how does it affect background checks?

The NICS Denial Notification Act, passed in 2022, makes it mandatory for the FBI to report all NICS denials to state and local governments within 24 hours of a failed background check. This increased reporting can lead to quicker enforcement actions, even in cases of false denials.

How accurate is the NICS system according to available data?

While the FBI claims NICS is 99% accurate, independent research and FBI's own data suggest otherwise. Records show at least one in four appeal denials were wrongful, and in 2023, only a tiny fraction of NICS denials led to convictions, indicating a high rate of false positives.

What legislative efforts are underway to address NICS system issues?

Gun Owners of America (GOA) is backing Thomas Massie's NICS Data Reporting Act, which passed the House. This bill aims to expose the NICS system's flaws and advocate for its abolition, arguing it's an unconstitutional burden and a source of false denials for law-abiding citizens.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Gun Owners of America

View all →