Buck Mayo Hilo and Cutback: High value EDCs

Published on July 12, 2008
Duration: 8:02

This review covers two discontinued Buck knives, the Hi-Lo and Cutback, designed by Tom Mayo. While inexpensive and featuring good construction, their solid stainless steel handles contribute to a weight that the reviewer finds slightly excessive for everyday carry. The Hi-Lo, weighing 4.3 ounces, and the smaller Cutback, at 3.3 ounces, both offer sharp blades made from 440C or 420HC steel and a solid lock-up, making them high-value options if found.

Quick Summary

The Buck Mayo Hi-Lo and Cutback are discontinued, inexpensive folding knives offering good construction and sharp blades, often made from 440C or 420HC steel. While their slim design is a plus, the solid stainless steel handles contribute to a weight that some find excessive for everyday carry, and the pivot-mounted clip limits carry options.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to Discontinued Buck Knives
  2. 00:20Buck Mayo Hi-Lo Design Overview
  3. 00:25Buck Mayo Cutback Knife
  4. 00:29Value and Construction of EDC Knives
  5. 00:34Hesitation to Review Discontinued Items
  6. 00:47Similar Buck Knives (TNT Version)
  7. 00:55Review of the Larger Hi-Lo Design
  8. 01:00Price Point and Features
  9. 01:09Solid Stainless Steel Handle Analysis
  10. 01:16Weight Concern: Over Four Ounces
  11. 01:25Advantages of the Design: Slimness
  12. 01:33Thin Handle and Lack of Reinforcements
  13. 01:53Blade Specifications: 440C Steel
  14. 02:01Sharpening and Sharpness Test
  15. 02:13Blade Shape and Utility
  16. 02:22Markings and Finish
  17. 02:30Dual Thumb Studs and Manufacturing Origin
  18. 02:39Lock-Up and Play
  19. 02:55Handle Ergonomics and Downsides
  20. 03:07Handle Material Temperature Issues
  21. 03:17Pivot Screw and Deployment Speed
  22. 03:28Pivot Mounted Clip and Carry Preference
  23. 03:42Ideal Design Improvements
  24. 03:51Handle Real Estate and Impact Device Potential
  25. 04:07Open Pillar Construction
  26. 04:12Value Proposition at $35
  27. 04:17Introducing the Smaller Cutback Model
  28. 04:31Cutback vs. Hi-Lo for EDC
  29. 04:38Comparison: Hi-Lo vs. Cutback Side-by-Side
  30. 04:42Limited Production Runs
  31. 04:54Conclusion: Great EDC Options if Found
  32. 05:00Similar Current Buck Models
  33. 05:17Final Thoughts and Thanks

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the Buck Mayo Hi-Lo and Cutback knives?

The Buck Mayo Hi-Lo and Cutback are discontinued folding knives designed by Tom Mayo. They are known for their inexpensive price point, good construction, and sharp blades, often made from 440C or 420HC steel, making them high-value EDC options if you can find them.

What are the main advantages of the Buck Mayo Hi-Lo and Cutback knives?

Key advantages include their very affordable price, solid lock-up with no play, sharp blades (after sharpening), slim and easy-to-carry design, and open pillar construction that prevents gunk buildup. The Hi-Lo also offers good reach for defensive use.

What are the disadvantages of the Buck Mayo Hi-Lo and Cutback knives?

The primary drawbacks are their solid stainless steel handles, which make them heavier than ideal for some EDC users, and the pivot-mounted clip, which limits carry options. The stainless steel also conducts heat and cold, making it uncomfortable in extreme temperatures.

Which Buck Mayo knife is better for everyday carry, the Hi-Lo or the Cutback?

For general everyday carry, the Cutback is often considered the better option due to its lighter weight (3.3 ounces) and smaller size. The Hi-Lo, weighing 4.3 ounces, might be preferred if more tactical or defensive capabilities are a priority.

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from nutnfancy

View all →