Hand Fit 1911 vs. Machine Fit 1911 (Worth Changing my EDC?)

Published on November 15, 2018
Duration: 12:56

The Yankee Marshal provides an expert comparison between a machine-fit Sig Sauer STX and a hand-fit Dan Wesson Specialist 1911, evaluating their suitability for his Every Day Carry (EDC). He details differences in slide serrations, sights, extractors, safeties, and crucially, the feel and performance of hand-fit versus machine-fit tolerances, concluding with trigger pull measurements. His assessment highlights how these factors influence his decision to switch his EDC to the Dan Wesson Specialist.

Quick Summary

The Yankee Marshal compares a machine-fit Sig Sauer STX (4 lbs 9 oz trigger) against a hand-fit Dan Wesson Specialist (3 lbs 2 oz trigger), highlighting differences in slide serrations, sights, and fitment. He concludes the hand-fit Specialist's tighter tolerances and superior trigger make it a better choice for his EDC.

Chapters

  1. 00:11Title Card: Hand Fit vs. Machined 1911s
  2. 02:16Switching EDC: Sig Sauer STX to Dan Wesson Specialist
  3. 03:21Shared 1911 Features
  4. 04:06Slide Serrations, Rails, and Sights Comparison
  5. 06:02Extractor and Guide Rod Differences
  6. 07:41Safety Lever Ergonomics
  7. 09:10Hand Fit vs. Machine Fit Evaluation
  8. 09:58Trigger Pull Comparison & EDC Decision

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between hand-fit and machine-fit 1911 pistols?

Hand-fit 1911s feature tighter tolerances and flush-fitting parts for a smoother action and more refined feel, like the Dan Wesson Specialist. Machine-fit models, such as the Sig Sauer STX, have looser tolerances, which can still be reliable but may not feel as precise or smooth during operation.

How does trigger pull weight affect EDC firearm choice?

A lighter and crisper trigger pull, like the 3 lbs 2 oz measured on the Dan Wesson Specialist, is generally preferred for an EDC firearm as it can contribute to faster, more accurate shooting under stress compared to a heavier pull like the Sig Sauer STX's 4 lbs 9 oz.

What are the advantages of a tactical ledge sight on a 1911?

A tactical ledge sight, found on the Dan Wesson Specialist, allows for one-handed slide manipulation by bracing the ledge against a belt or holster if injured. This is a practical feature for an EDC firearm.

Why is fitment important in a 1911 pistol?

Fitment directly impacts the perceived quality and performance of a 1911. Tighter fitment, achieved through hand-fitting, reduces play between parts, leading to a smoother slide action, better accuracy potential, and a more premium feel compared to looser machine-fit tolerances.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →