R&R | 1911’s For Carry?

Published on January 15, 2026
Duration: 9:29

This video provides an expert-level comparison of the 1911 platform versus modern polymer handguns for concealed carry, drawing on the host's experienced perspective. It delves into the practical considerations of weight, capacity, manual safeties, and trigger characteristics, ultimately guiding viewers to make an informed decision based on personal proficiency and practical advantages. The host, with high authority, emphasizes that while the 1911 has merits, modern options often present superior utility for everyday carry unless a deep personal preference or specific skill set exists.

Quick Summary

For concealed carry, modern polymer handguns like the Glock 19 often present more practical advantages than the 1911 due to their lighter weight, higher capacity (15+ rounds), and simpler striker-fired operation. While the 1911 offers superior ergonomics and trigger, its weight and manual safety requirements make it less ideal for everyday carry unless the user possesses exceptional proficiency.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro and Reloading
  2. 01:311911 Pros
  3. 03:02Familiarity vs. Modernity
  4. 04:30Weight and Capacity Comparisons
  5. 07:10Manual Safety and Action
  6. 08:01Final Verdict

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a 1911 still a good choice for concealed carry?

While the 1911 platform boasts excellent ergonomics and trigger, it's generally less practical for concealed carry than modern polymer handguns due to its heavier weight and lower capacity (7-9 rounds vs. 15+). Proficiency with its manual safety is also crucial.

What are the main advantages of a Glock 19 for concealed carry compared to a 1911?

The Glock 19 offers a significant advantage in weight, capacity (typically 15+ rounds), and operational simplicity as a striker-fired pistol. Its polymer frame is also more comfortable for all-day carry for many users.

Should I carry a 1911 if I'm very experienced with it?

If you are highly experienced and 'fluent' with the 1911's manual of arms, including its single-action operation and manual safety, carrying one can be justifiable. However, for most, modern options offer more practical benefits.

What are the key differences in firearm operation between a 1911 and a Glock 19?

A 1911 is typically a single-action pistol requiring a manual safety to be engaged and disengaged. A Glock 19 is a striker-fired pistol with a simpler trigger pull and no external manual safety, relying on internal safeties.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from The Gun Dungeon

View all →