From Flop to Top: Iconic Guns That Were Initially Rejected — GMP #299

Published on September 5, 2025
Duration: 39:18

This episode of the Guns Magazine podcast explores iconic firearms that were initially met with skepticism or outright rejection before becoming highly successful. Hosts Brent Wheat and Roy Huntington discuss the historical context, design challenges, and eventual market acceptance of firearms like the Winchester 1873, Colt Single Action Army, AR-15, and Glock, highlighting how initial perceptions can evolve over time.

Quick Summary

Firearms like the Winchester 1873, Colt Single Action Army, AR-15, and Glock were initially met with skepticism due to their design, caliber, or materials. Despite early criticism, these guns eventually became iconic due to their innovation, adaptability, and eventual market acceptance, proving that initial rejection doesn't preclude lasting success.

Chapters

  1. 00:04:00Introduction
  2. 00:16:00Winchester 1873: The Gun That Won the West?
  3. 00:44:00Marlin 336: A Poor Man's Winchester?
  4. 00:47:00Colt Single Action Army: Cowboy Icon's Rocky Start
  5. 01:13:00Colt Python: The Expensive Revolver
  6. 01:43:00Browning High Power: The Professional's Gun
  7. 02:11:00M1 Garand: Military's Reluctant Rifle
  8. 02:23:00AR-15: The 'Space Gun' Revolution
  9. 02:27:00Short-Barreled Bolt-Action Rifles
  10. 02:57:00Polymer Handguns: Glock and the Future
  11. 03:29:00Sig Sauer: The European Influence
  12. 03:41:00Conclusion and Future Episodes

Frequently Asked Questions

Which firearms were initially rejected but later became iconic?

Several firearms initially faced skepticism, including the Winchester 1873, Colt Single Action Army, Marlin 336, Colt Python, Browning High Power, M1 Garand, AR-15, and early polymer handguns like the Glock 17. These guns were often criticized for their design, caliber, price, or materials before eventually gaining widespread popularity and historical significance.

Why was the Winchester 1873 initially unpopular?

The Winchester 1873, despite its famous marketing slogan, was initially not very popular because many users, like buffalo hunters, preferred more powerful single-shot rifles in larger calibers such as the .45-70 or .45-90. The 1873's .44-40 caliber and steel receiver were seen as less potent by some.

What led to the eventual success of the AR-15?

The AR-15, initially viewed as a 'tinkertoy' due to its polymer and aluminum construction and small .223 caliber, eventually became America's most popular rifle. Its modularity, ease of manufacturing, and adaptability for various roles contributed to its widespread adoption and iconic status.

How did polymer handguns like Glock gain acceptance?

Early polymer handguns, such as the HK VP70 and Glock 17, were met with distrust due to their plastic construction. However, their durability, reliability, ease of maintenance, and cost-effectiveness, especially for law enforcement, eventually overcame initial skepticism, making them ubiquitous.

More General Videos You Might Like

More from GUNS and American Handgunner Magazines

View all →