2-Gun Action Challenge Match: SVT40 vs M1 Garand

Published on October 20, 2013
Duration: 11:28

This 2-Gun Action Challenge match pitted an SVT-40 against an M1 Garand after an FG42 reproduction failed. The M1 Garand ultimately won due to its superior aperture sights for long-range accuracy and easier top-loading system for competitive stages. The match highlighted the practical differences in ergonomics and sighting systems between these historical semi-automatic rifles in a dynamic shooting environment.

Quick Summary

The M1 Garand won the 2-Gun Action Challenge match against the SVT-40, largely due to its superior aperture sights for long-range accuracy and an easier top-loading system for competitive stages. The SVT-40 was substituted for a failed FG42 reproduction.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: 2-Gun Action Challenge Match
  2. 01:52FG42 Failure & SVT-40 Substitution
  3. 02:20Stage 1: Pistol Competition (1911 vs P38)
  4. 03:19Stage 2: Short-Range Rifle Accuracy
  5. 05:21Stage 3: Long-Range Rifle Silhouettes
  6. 08:09Stage 4: Movement and Loading Drill
  7. 08:57Final Results & Technical Analysis

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the outcome of the 2-Gun Action Challenge match between the SVT-40 and M1 Garand?

The M1 Garand, shot by Ian McCollum, won the overall match with a total time of 291.87 seconds. The SVT-40, used by Karl Kasarda, was slightly slower, particularly in stages requiring long-range accuracy.

Why was the SVT-40 used instead of the FG42 in the competition?

The reproduction FG42 experienced a critical equipment failure, specifically a broken wooden stock, before the first stage of the competition. This led to Karl Kasarda switching to a Soviet SVT-40 to maintain the semi-automatic rifle comparison.

What advantages did the M1 Garand have over the SVT-40 in this match?

The M1 Garand's aperture sights offered superior accuracy for target acquisition at longer distances. Additionally, its top-loading en-bloc clip system proved easier to manage while moving compared to the SVT-40's detachable magazine.

Related News

All News →

More Range & Competition Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →