BUG Match: Serbu Super Shorty vs MIL Thunder 5

Published on September 27, 2025
Duration: 13:46

This guide analyzes the performance of the Serbu Super Shorty and MIL Thunder 5 in a Back-Up Gun (BUG) match, as demonstrated by Ian McCollum and Matt Haught. It covers their use of different buckshot loads, challenges faced during competitive stages including reloading and accuracy issues due to spread, and concludes with a practical assessment of their defensive utility. The analysis highlights the distinct characteristics and limitations of each firearm.

Quick Summary

The Serbu Super Shorty (12ga pump-action) and MIL Thunder 5 (.410/.45 Colt revolver) were compared in a BUG match. The Thunder 5 showed extreme, uncontrollable buckshot spread and difficult reloads, deemed 'irresponsible' for defense. The Super Shorty was effective up close but had cycling issues and handling quirks.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to BUG Match
  2. 00:34MIL Thunder 5 Overview
  3. 01:22Serbu Super Shorty Overview
  4. 02:41Stage 1 Performance
  5. 04:31Stage 2: Steel Targets
  6. 05:40Stage 3: Paper Targets
  7. 07:48Stage 4: Movement and Barriers
  8. 09:41Final Assessment and Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Serbu Super Shorty and the MIL Thunder 5?

The Serbu Super Shorty is a 12-gauge pump-action shotgun with a 2+1 capacity, known for its compact size and folding grip. The MIL Thunder 5 is a .410 bore/.45 Colt double-action revolver with a 5-round capacity and a short barrel, predating the Taurus Judge.

What were the main performance issues observed during the BUG match?

The MIL Thunder 5 faced significant reloading challenges due to its short ejector rod and exhibited an uncontrollable spread pattern from its buckshot. The Serbu Super Shorty experienced some cycling issues and its vertical grip could lead to short-stroking.

Are the Serbu Super Shorty and MIL Thunder 5 recommended for self-defense?

The speakers concluded that while fun for a match, both have practical drawbacks. The Thunder 5's extreme spread makes it 'irresponsible' for defense, while the Super Shorty's handling requires specific training to overcome potential reliability issues.

What type of ammunition was used in the comparison?

For the MIL Thunder 5, three-pellet triple-ought buckshot was used. For the Serbu Super Shorty, nine-pellet low-recoil buckshot was utilized. Both firearms were also chambered for .410 bore and .45 Colt respectively.

Related News

All News →

More Range & Competition Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →