Is 40 S&W Dying? | Why It May Be and Why It Shouldn’t

Published on October 8, 2024
Duration: 15:32

This video explores the perceived decline of the 40 S&W cartridge, presenting arguments for why it may be fading and why it shouldn't. Key factors discussed include the lack of 40 S&W in modern micro-compact pistols, perceived recoil, and lower magazine capacity compared to 9mm. Conversely, arguments for its continued relevance highlight its superior ballistics over 9mm, its efficiency, its capability to achieve major power factor in competitive shooting like USPSA, and its versatility with conversion barrels for other calibers.

Quick Summary

The 40 S&W cartridge is perceived as declining due to its absence in modern micro-compact pistols and concerns over recoil and capacity. However, it remains relevant for its superior ballistics over 9mm, its ability to score 'major' power factor in competitions like USPSA, and its versatility with conversion barrels for other calibers.

Chapters

  1. 00:44Introduction: Is 40 S&W Dead?
  2. 01:26Point 1: Lack of 40 S&W in Modern Compacts
  3. 02:55Point 2: The Recoil Complaint
  4. 04:14Point 3: Capacity Differences
  5. 05:09Point 4: Ballistics vs. Perceived Value
  6. 06:15Why 40 S&W Shouldn't Die: Ballistic Efficiency
  7. 09:05Why 40 S&W Shouldn't Die: Caliber Versatility
  8. 10:09Why 40 S&W Shouldn't Die: Shooting Sports (USPSA/IDPA)
  9. 12:24Why 40 S&W Shouldn't Die: The 10mm Connection
  10. 14:42Conclusion: Arguments for 40 S&W

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is the 40 S&W cartridge considered by some to be 'dying'?

The 40 S&W is perceived as dying primarily because it's not featured in the latest micro-compact, double-stack pistols dominating the concealed carry market. Additionally, complaints about its recoil and lower magazine capacity compared to 9mm contribute to this perception.

What are the main arguments for the continued relevance of the 40 S&W cartridge?

Arguments for 40 S&W include its superior ballistic efficiency and energy output compared to 9mm, its ability to achieve 'major' power factor in competitive shooting like USPSA, and its versatility through conversion barrels for other calibers like 9mm and 357 Sig.

How does the recoil of 40 S&W compare to 9mm?

While often described as 'snappy,' the recoil of 40 S&W is generally considered by many to be a 9mm with 'a little more oomph.' For individuals not highly sensitive to recoil, it's not typically perceived as significantly more painful or causing excessive muzzle rise.

Can 40 S&W firearms be converted to other calibers?

Yes, firearms chambered in 40 S&W can often be fitted with conversion barrels for calibers like 9mm and 357 Sig. This offers a significant advantage in terms of practice ammunition cost and ballistic experimentation, a versatility not usually found when converting from 9mm.

Related News

All News →

More Range & Competition Videos You Might Like

More from The Gun Dungeon

View all →