Best 9mm Handpew?

Published on December 6, 2024
Duration: 76:25

This video provides an in-depth comparison of three popular handgun platforms: the Sig Sauer P226 Zev, Glock 17 Gen 3, and Springfield Armory Prodigy (a 2011 variant). The presenter, with significant experience, discusses the pros and cons of each, focusing on customization, reliability, shooting characteristics, and value. Key takeaways include the Prodigy's potential for high performance with aftermarket upgrades at a lower cost than premium 2011s, the Glock's inherent reliability and customization potential, and the Sig P226's balance of reliability and upgradeability, though often at a higher price point.

Quick Summary

The Springfield Armory Prodigy, when upgraded with V8 ports and a trigger job, can shoot as flat and fast as a Staccato XC for a fraction of the cost. While premium 2011s like the Staccato P are excellent, the Prodigy offers a superior value proposition for achieving high-end performance through aftermarket modifications.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Pardons
  2. 00:56Handgun Collection Overview
  3. 01:17The Big Three Debate: Glock vs Sig vs 2011
  4. 01:45Springfield Prodigy (2011)
  5. 01:58Sig Sauer P226 Zev Deep Dive
  6. 03:02Sig P226 Pricing & History
  7. 04:15Sig's Position in the Market
  8. 05:02Glock 17 vs. Glock 19 Size Comparison
  9. 05:49Glock 17 Grip & Carry Experience
  10. 07:31Glock vs. Sig Grip Feel
  11. 07:49Glock Aesthetics & Customization
  12. 08:32Glock 17 Stock Configuration
  13. 09:03Glock 17 Aftermarket Parts
  14. 09:37Sig P226 Zev Customization & Performance
  15. 10:22Glock Reliability
  16. 10:42Customization Reliability Issues (Sig)
  17. 11:35Compensator Impact on Reliability
  18. 12:06Glock's 'Good to Go' Reliability
  19. 12:44Springfield Prodigy (2011) Upgrades
  20. 13:37Prodigy vs. Staccato XC Performance
  21. 14:11Prodigy Value Proposition
  22. 14:37Prodigy V8 Ports Upgrade
  23. 15:25Ports vs. Compensator Reliability
  24. 16:34Prodigy Trigger Job & Magwell
  25. 18:00Holosun ACSS Optic Features
  26. 18:53Comparing the Three Platforms
  27. 19:13Prodigy Durability & Range Toy Status
  28. 19:42Nightstand Gun Preferences
  29. 20:12Speed Comparison: Glock vs. Sig vs. Prodigy
  30. 20:26Prodigy Port Fouling
  31. 21:16Overall Self-Defense Recommendations
  32. 21:45Choosing One Handgun
  33. 22:04Cost Comparison: Sig vs. Prodigy vs. Glock
  34. 22:35Aesthetics & Vibe Comparison
  35. 23:39Size and Weight Comparison
  36. 24:07Practicality for Carry
  37. 24:52H&K Firearms Discussion
  38. 25:16Sig P226 Action Type
  39. 25:30HK vs. Glock Reliability
  40. 26:01Glock 17 Size Perception
  41. 26:09Sig P226 Zev Recoil Spring Issues
  42. 27:00Sig P226 Zev & Prodigy Trigger Jobs
  43. 27:43Sig P226 Trigger Adjustability
  44. 28:13Red Dot Sight Market & Value
  45. 30:37Glock Iron Sights
  46. 30:54Holosun ACSS Optic Price & Recommendation
  47. 31:45Sig P226 Zev Optic Co-witness Issues
  48. 32:26Optic Co-witnessing Explained
  49. 33:06Armory Craft Compensator for P226
  50. 34:13Sig P226 Aftermarket Support
  51. 35:30Sig P226 Comp Reliability & Ammo Choice
  52. 36:14Bullpup Shotgun Experience
  53. 36:48Handgun Model Recap
  54. 37:13Sig P226 Drop Safety
  55. 37:21Sig P226 Safety Mechanism Issues
  56. 38:05P226 Aftermarket Parts Sources
  57. 38:32Grip Comfort Comparison
  58. 39:17Sig P226 Zev Origin Story
  59. 40:05P226 Zev Features
  60. 40:25P226 Zev Slide Cuts & Barrel
  61. 40:45P226 Iron Sight Co-witness Desire
  62. 41:13P226 Zev Model Identification
  63. 41:31Prodigy Gas Pedal Takedown Lever Interest
  64. 42:04Takedown Lever vs. Other Mods
  65. 42:39Binary Trigger Discussion
  66. 43:47Binary Trigger Reliability
  67. 44:03Binary Trigger Cost & Value
  68. 45:44Binary Triggers for AKs
  69. 46:11Binary Trigger Video Reference
  70. 46:21AK Collection Mention
  71. 46:28Pistol Showcase Recap
  72. 46:49Drop Safe Discussion
  73. 47:28Ports vs. Compensators Preference
  74. 47:47Compensator Versatility (Suppressor Use)
  75. 48:09Ports vs. Compensators Effectiveness
  76. 49:04Ports vs. Compensators Weight
  77. 49:27Ports vs. Compensators Velocity Impact
  78. 50:28Ports vs. Compensators Cost
  79. 50:47Ports vs. Compensators Reliability
  80. 51:28Ports vs. Compensators Muzzle Flash & Concussion
  81. 52:49Final Comparison: P226 Zev vs. Glock 17 vs. Prodigy
  82. 53:03FN Firearms Discussion
  83. 53:33FN 509 Tactical Comps
  84. 54:11FN 45 Tactical Size
  85. 54:26Concealed Carry Philosophy (Raw Dogging)
  86. 55:08Glock 21 Mention
  87. 56:00Glock 17 Stock Upgrades
  88. 56:47P365 CCW Reliability
  89. 57:01Sig P320 Dislike
  90. 58:05P320 Military Contract & Cost
  91. 58:27Glock 17 & P320 as Issue Firearms
  92. 58:30Glock Customization Cost vs. FN
  93. 58:45Holster Size & Flashlight Carry
  94. 59:06P320 Frame Options
  95. 01:00:02Primary Firearm Discussion
  96. 01:00:15Rifle Dynamics Short Barrel AK
  97. 01:00:29300 Blackout AR
  98. 01:00:40Glock 19 with Mass Driver Comp
  99. 01:01:36Glock 19 Comp Practicality
  100. 01:02:08Radian Ramjet & Afterburner Cost
  101. 01:02:22Strike Industries Products
  102. 01:02:51Canik TP9 Combat Elite Executive
  103. 01:03:04Renting Firearms Before Purchase
  104. 01:03:29FN 509 Tactical Comps (Removable)
  105. 01:04:19Compensator Installation Difficulty
  106. 01:05:11Mass Driver Comp Benefits
  107. 01:05:11Palmetto State Armory AKs
  108. 01:06:16PSA AK Quality & Value
  109. 01:07:29Kimber 2011 vs. Staccato
  110. 01:08:19Staccato Price Markup
  111. 01:09:03Prodigy vs. Kimber/Staccato Build Cost
  112. 01:10:03P80 Glock Clones
  113. 01:11:01Glock Frame vs. P80 Frame Preference
  114. 01:11:37Canik TP9 Value
  115. 01:11:52Glock vs. P226 Recommendation
  116. 01:12:13Value Proposition in Firearms
  117. 01:13:14Prodigy Barrel & Slide Aesthetics
  118. 01:13:29Kimber 2011s & Micro9
  119. 01:14:44Final Handgun Recap & Favorite

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Sig P226, Glock 17, and Springfield Prodigy?

The Sig P226 Zev is a premium, metal-framed handgun known for reliability and upgradeability, though often expensive. The Glock 17 Gen 3 is a highly reliable, polymer-framed pistol with vast customization options and a lower price point. The Springfield Armory Prodigy, a 2011 variant, offers excellent shooting dynamics, especially when upgraded, providing a high-performance platform at a competitive price.

Which handgun is best for self-defense among the Sig P226, Glock 17, and Springfield Prodigy?

For pure reliability in self-defense, the Glock 17 is often recommended due to its proven track record and simplicity. The Sig P226 offers a good balance of reliability and shootability. The Springfield Prodigy, with its flat shooting characteristics, excels in speed and accuracy, making it a strong contender if maintained properly.

Can aftermarket modifications like compensators and ports affect handgun reliability?

Yes, aftermarket modifications like compensators and ports can impact reliability. Compensators, especially larger ones, can alter slide cycling, potentially requiring recoil spring adjustments. Ports, while effective for recoil reduction, can also lead to increased fouling and may require specific maintenance. Extensive internal trigger modifications can also compromise safety mechanisms if not done correctly.

What is the value proposition of the Springfield Armory Prodigy compared to premium 2011s like Staccato?

The Springfield Armory Prodigy offers a significant value advantage. A well-upgraded Prodigy, costing under $2,000 with ports, trigger job, and optic, can shoot as flat and fast as a Staccato XC, while a Staccato P alone costs $2,500 before upgrades. This makes the Prodigy an excellent choice for achieving high-end performance on a budget.

What are the benefits of a 'gas pedal' takedown lever on a handgun?

A 'gas pedal' takedown lever significantly improves control by providing a dedicated, ergonomic spot for the support hand's thumb. This placement aids in managing muzzle flip and recoil, allowing for a more stable shooting platform and better overall weapon control during rapid fire.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from MuzzleBroke

View all →