BEST American Gun in WW2? | Wall of Guns Review

Published on February 21, 2021
Duration: 25:27

This comprehensive review by Arm&Gun analyzes the best American small arms of World War II, simulating a soldier's choice in Normandy. The expert instructor details the M3A1 Grease Gun, two Thompson variants (M1A1 and 1928A1), the M1 Garand, and the M1918A2 BAR, comparing their design, rate of fire, and tactical applications. The analysis highlights the .45 ACP versus .30-06 calibers and concludes with a personal preference for the Thompson 1928A1 in European urban combat.

Quick Summary

The best American WWII small arms reviewed include the M3A1 Grease Gun, Thompson M1A1 and 1928A1, M1 Garand, and M1918A2 BAR. The .30-06 caliber offers superior range and power over .45 ACP. The Thompson 1928A1 is favored for urban combat due to its versatility and CQB features.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: WWII American Small Arms Choice
  2. 02:02M3A1 Grease Gun Review
  3. 06:06Thompson M1A1 Review
  4. 08:41Thompson 1928A1 Review
  5. 11:13Caliber Comparison: .45 ACP vs .30-06
  6. 12:07M1 Garand Review
  7. 15:40M1918A2 BAR Review
  8. 19:24Conclusion: Best WWII Gun Choice

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the primary American small arms discussed for WWII combat?

The review covers the M3A1 Grease Gun, two Thompson submachine gun variants (M1A1 and 1928A1), the M1 Garand semi-automatic rifle, and the M1918A2 BAR light machine gun, with the M1911 assumed as the standard sidearm.

How do the .45 ACP and .30-06 calibers compare for WWII firearms?

The .30-06 caliber, used in rifles like the M1 Garand and BAR, offers significantly greater range, a flatter trajectory, and armor-piercing capabilities compared to the .45 ACP used in submachine guns.

Which WWII American firearm did the expert instructor prefer for European urban combat?

The expert instructor selected the Thompson 1928A1, citing its versatility, higher rate of fire, ability to use drum magazines, and detachable stock for close-quarters combat in urban environments.

What are the key differences between the Thompson M1A1 and 1928A1?

The M1A1 is a simplified wartime version favoring stick magazines and has a lower rate of fire (650-675 RPM), while the 1928A1 retains classic features, accepts drum magazines, and has a higher rate of fire (800-850 RPM).

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Arm&Gun

View all →