Bullpups are Unpopular for a Reason

Published on October 21, 2023
Duration: 26:32

This review by Hop critically examines the practicality of bullpup rifles, comparing the KelTec RDB 17 and Desert Tech MDRX. The analysis highlights significant drawbacks in accessory mounting, positional shooting, and malfunction clearance compared to traditional platforms like the AR-15. The speaker, an experienced firearms reviewer, suggests bullpups remain niche due to cost and the availability of comparable compact options.

Quick Summary

Bullpup rifles offer compact size with long barrels but face significant drawbacks: limited accessory rail space hinders optics and laser mounting, rear-heavy ergonomics complicate barricade shooting, and malfunction clearance is often more complex than on AR-15s. High costs also contribute to their niche market status.

Chapters

  1. 00:00The Bullpup Advantage
  2. 01:19Test Rifles: KelTec RDB vs. Desert Tech MDRX
  3. 02:33Accessory Mounting and Rail Space
  4. 07:24Positional Shooting and Ergonomics
  5. 10:01Reliability and Malfunctions
  6. 15:09Market Viability and Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main disadvantages of bullpup rifles compared to AR-15s?

Bullpup rifles often suffer from limited accessory mounting space, making it difficult to attach optics, lights, and lasers. Their rear-heavy balance can also complicate shooting from cover or unconventional positions, and clearing malfunctions can be more complex than with an AR-15.

Why are bullpup rifles not more popular in the civilian market?

Bullpups remain unpopular due to their higher cost compared to traditional platforms like the AR-15. Additionally, the availability of compact AR pistols with braces previously offered similar size benefits for less money, reducing the perceived value of bullpups for many consumers.

How does the KelTec RDB 17 handle brass ejection?

The KelTec RDB 17 features downward brass ejection, which is advantageous for suppressed shooting by directing gas away from the shooter's face. However, hot brass can sometimes fall onto the shooter's arms or legs.

What makes accessory mounting difficult on bullpup rifles like the Desert Tech MDRX?

The Desert Tech MDRX, like many bullpups, has limited rail space. This can cause interference issues, such as an LPVO bell potentially blocking the mounting of standard laser aiming modules like the PEQ-15.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Hop

View all →