Federal Punch vs CCI Stingers

Published on June 4, 2023
Duration: 14:29

This review compares Federal Punch and CCI Stinger .22LR ammunition using both a short-barreled pistol and a rifle. The CCI Stinger excels from a rifle, showing significant expansion and a large temporary cavity. However, the Federal Punch demonstrates superior penetration from a short-barreled handgun, making it a better choice for personal defense in that platform.

Quick Summary

For short-barreled handguns, Federal Punch is recommended for .22LR self-defense due to its superior penetration (19.5 inches in gel) compared to CCI Stinger (12 inches). CCI Stinger excels from rifles, offering significant expansion but less penetration.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Federal Punch vs CCI Stinger
  2. 00:51Test Firearms: Pistol & Rifle Setup
  3. 01:28Velocity & Energy Data Comparison
  4. 02:08Projectile Design & Gel Testing Setup
  5. 03:21Handgun Ballistics Gel Results
  6. 06:01Rifle Ballistics Gel Results
  7. 11:09Conclusion: Best Use Cases

Frequently Asked Questions

Which .22LR ammo is better for handgun self-defense: Federal Punch or CCI Stinger?

For short-barreled handguns, Federal Punch is generally recommended. In ballistic gel tests, it achieved deeper penetration (19.5 inches) compared to CCI Stinger (12 inches) from a 3.6-inch barrel, which is crucial for effective self-defense.

How does CCI Stinger perform from a rifle compared to Federal Punch?

From a 16-inch rifle, CCI Stinger shows impressive expansion and a large temporary cavity, though its penetration is limited to 11.5 inches. Federal Punch also expands well and maintains similar penetration to its handgun performance.

What are the key differences in bullet design between Federal Punch and CCI Stinger?

Federal Punch uses a flat nose solid projectile, designed for reliable penetration. CCI Stinger features a copper-plated hollow point, engineered to expand significantly at higher velocities, making it more effective from longer barrels.

What are the tested velocities for Federal Punch and CCI Stinger from a pistol and rifle?

From a 3.6-inch pistol, Federal Punch averaged 1235 fps and CCI Stinger averaged 1159 fps. From a 16-inch rifle, Federal Punch averaged 1604 fps and CCI Stinger averaged 1572 fps.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Iraqveteran8888

View all →