Pick One: G1 (FAL) vs G3 (H&K) w/ John Keene

Published on August 2, 2025
Duration: 1:04

This video compares the FN FAL (G1) and H&K G3 battle rifles, with John Keene favoring the G3 for its lighter weight and Ian McCollum preferring the FAL for its left-hand friendly charging handle. Both rifles are acknowledged as top-tier military firearms with extensive service histories. The discussion highlights specific ergonomic differences, such as the FAL's charging handle placement versus the G3's overall lighter carry weight.

Quick Summary

John Keene prefers the H&K G3 over the FN FAL (G1) because it is a lighter rifle to carry, despite both being excellent battle rifles. Ian McCollum leans towards the FAL, noting its charging handle placement is more left-hand friendly.

Chapters

  1. 00:00G1 (FAL) vs G3 (H&K): The Ultimate Choice
  2. 00:06John Keene's Pick: The Lighter G3
  3. 00:16Battle Rifle Service Records
  4. 00:31Ian McCollum's Pick: The Left-Hand Friendly FAL
  5. 00:42FAL Ergonomic Flaws vs G3 Charging

Frequently Asked Questions

Which rifle is lighter, the FN FAL (G1) or the H&K G3?

John Keene states that the H&K G3 is a lighter rifle to carry than the FN FAL (G1), making it his preferred choice for a soldier. Both are considered excellent battle rifles.

What ergonomic advantage does the FN FAL have over the H&K G3?

Ian McCollum prefers the FN FAL (G1) because its charging handle placement is more left-hand friendly compared to the H&K G3. This is a key factor in his choice between the two battle rifles.

What are the key technical differences between the G1 (FAL) and G3?

The H&K G3 uses a roller-delayed blowback action and is noted for being lighter. The FN FAL (G1) uses a short-stroke gas piston and is favored by some for its charging handle ergonomics.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →