Pick One: G1 (FAL) vs G3 (H&K) w/ John Keene

Published on August 2, 2025
Duration: 1:04

This video features John Keene and Ian McCollum discussing the merits of the FN FAL (G1) and the H&K G3 battle rifles. Keene favors the G3 for its lighter carrying weight, while McCollum leans towards the FAL due to its more left-hand friendly charging handle, despite acknowledging the FAL's selector switch can be accidentally bumped. Both rifles are recognized as top-tier battle rifles with extensive military service histories.

Quick Summary

John Keene and Ian McCollum compare the FN FAL (G1) and H&K G3 battle rifles. Keene prefers the G3 for its lighter weight, calling it a 'soldier's pick.' McCollum favors the FAL for its left-hand friendly charging handle, despite noting potential issues with its selector switch. Both rifles are recognized for their extensive military service.

Chapters

  1. 00:00The Ultimate Choice: FAL vs G3
  2. 00:06John's Choice: The G3
  3. 00:16Service Records
  4. 00:31Ian's Choice: The FAL
  5. 00:42FAL Ergonomic Flaws

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the FN FAL (G1) and the H&K G3 battle rifles?

The H&K G3 is often chosen for its lighter carrying weight, while the FN FAL (G1) is praised for its more left-hand friendly charging handle, though its selector switch can be prone to accidental engagement. Both are highly regarded battle rifles.

Which rifle is considered more ergonomic for left-handed shooters between the FAL and G3?

Ian McCollum suggests the FN FAL (G1) is more left-hand friendly, primarily due to the placement of its charging handle compared to the H&K G3.

What caliber are the FN FAL (G1) and H&K G3 typically chambered in?

Both the FN FAL (G1) and the H&K G3 are commonly chambered in the 7.62x51mm NATO cartridge, a standard military rifle round.

What operating systems do the FN FAL (G1) and H&K G3 use?

The FN FAL (G1) utilizes a short-stroke gas piston system, while the H&K G3 operates using a roller-delayed blowback mechanism.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →