S&W Sigma - Ain't No Glock - TheFireArmGuy

Published on June 27, 2012
Duration: 4:59

This video provides an experienced firearms reviewer's critical assessment of the Smith & Wesson Sigma. The reviewer details frequent reliability issues, specifically 'stovepipe' failures to eject, which significantly impacted his shooting experience. While acknowledging its affordability, the reviewer cannot recommend it for self-defense due to these concerns, suggesting it primarily as a range toy. A direct comparison with the Glock 19 highlights the Sigma's shortcomings in consistency and reliability.

Quick Summary

The Smith & Wesson Sigma exhibits significant reliability issues, including frequent 'stovepipe' failures to eject (2-3 per 16-round magazine), making it challenging to maintain a shooting rhythm. While affordable at $320 MSRP, these malfunctions lead an experienced reviewer to deem it unsuitable for self-defense, recommending it only as a range toy and preferring the more reliable Glock 19.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Shooting Demo
  2. 00:17Sigma vs. Glock Comparison
  3. 01:08Accuracy Assessment
  4. 01:52Reliability Issues (Stovepipes)
  5. 02:51Sigma vs. Glock 19 Detailed
  6. 03:40Price & Final Verdict

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main reliability issues with the Smith & Wesson Sigma?

The primary reliability issue highlighted is frequent failure to eject, commonly known as 'stovepipes'. These malfunctions occurred 2-3 times per 16-round magazine during testing, significantly disrupting the shooting experience and confidence in the firearm.

How does the S&W Sigma compare to the Glock 19 in terms of performance?

Despite some superficial similarities in size and capacity, the S&W Sigma is noted to be significantly less reliable than the Glock 19. The reviewer experienced consistent malfunctions with the Sigma, while the Glock 19 performed reliably, leading to a clear preference for the Glock.

Is the S&W Sigma recommended for self-defense?

No, the reviewer explicitly states he cannot recommend the S&W Sigma for self-defense due to its significant reliability concerns. He suggests it is best suited as a range toy or a secondary firearm, not for critical situations where dependable function is paramount.

What is the price point of the S&W Sigma?

The Smith & Wesson Sigma has an MSRP of $320 when purchased new. While this makes it an affordable option, the reviewer emphasizes that the low cost does not compensate for the firearm's performance and reliability issues.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from TheFirearmGuy

View all →