Spyderco Bowie?! The Province

Published on June 13, 2020
Duration: 26:34

This review of the Spyderco FB45GP Province Bowie knife focuses on its 'second cool' appeal as a collectible rather than a practical tool. While acknowledging its Bowie blade shape and Spyderco's reputation, the reviewer highlights significant drawbacks in handle ergonomics, blade finishing, and sheath quality for its price point. Competitive options are presented that offer superior value and design in the collectible Bowie category.

Quick Summary

The Spyderco Province Bowie knife is primarily a collectible, praised for its homage to Old West designs but criticized for poor handle ergonomics, subpar blade finishing for its price, and a basic sheath. While its CPM 4V steel is robust, practical use is discouraged, with alternatives like Bark River and Case Knives offering better value and design for collectors.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: The Importance of 'Second Cool'
  2. 01:10Spyderco Province Bowie Knife Overview
  3. 03:00Philosophy of Use: Collectibility vs. Fighting Knife
  4. 06:00Handle Design Criticisms
  5. 08:00Blade Finishing and Steel Choice
  6. 10:00Competitive Options: Bark River Bowie
  7. 12:00Competitive Options: Case Knives Bowie Hunter
  8. 14:00Competitive Options: NRA Bowie & Other Collectibles
  9. 17:00Final Verdict: Buy or Not Buy?

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main criticisms of the Spyderco Province Bowie knife?

The Spyderco Province Bowie knife receives criticism for its handle ergonomics, described as too short and square with a downturn that can be uncomfortable. The blade finishing is also noted as a letdown for its price point, lacking polish. The sheath is considered adequate but basic, lacking features expected on a premium knife.

Is the Spyderco Province Bowie knife recommended for practical use like survival or EDC?

No, the reviewer strongly advises against using the Spyderco Province for practical tasks like survival or everyday carry (EDC). The handle ergonomics are deemed unsuitable for demanding work, and its high price and collectible nature make it ill-suited for hard use.

What makes the Spyderco Province Bowie knife a collectible?

The Spyderco Province Bowie knife is considered collectible due to its homage to classic Old West fighting knives and the likelihood of it being discontinued by Spyderco. This discontinuation often leads to increased demand and market value among collectors over time.

What are some better alternatives to the Spyderco Province for collectors?

The Bark River Limited Edition 8.5" Bowie and the Case Knives Bowie Hunter are presented as superior alternatives. These knives offer better handle design, superior blade finishing, more appealing presentation (like box art and sheaths), and often better value for collectors.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from nutnfancy

View all →